Dunagan William Claiborne, Littenberg Benjamin, Ewald Gregory A, Jones Catherine A, Emery Valerie Beckham, Waterman Brian M, Silverman Daniel C, Rogers Joseph G
Division of General Medical Sciences, Washington University School of Medicine, St Louis, Missouri, USA.
J Card Fail. 2005 Jun;11(5):358-65. doi: 10.1016/j.cardfail.2004.12.004.
Heart failure is a common and important cause of morbidity and mortality. Disease management offers promise in reducing the need for hospitalization and improving quality of life for heart failure patients, but experimental data on the efficacy of such programs are limited.
A total of 151 patients hospitalized with heart failure were randomized to usual care or scheduled telephone calls by specially trained nurses promoting self-management and guideline-based therapy as prescribed by primary physicians. Nurses also screened patients for heart failure exacerbations, which they managed with supplemental diuretics or by contacting the primary physician for instructions. Outcomes included time to hospital encounter, mortality, number and cost of hospitalizations, functional status, and satisfaction with care. Intervention patients had a longer time to encounter (hazard ratio [HR] = 0.67; 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.47-0.96; P = .029), hospital readmission (HR = 0.67; CI 0.46-0.99; P = .045), and heart failure-specific readmission (HR = 0.62; CI 0.38-1.03; P = .063). The number of admissions, hospital days, and hospital costs were significantly lower during the first 6 months after intervention but not at 1 year. The intervention had little effect on functional status, mortality, and satisfaction with care.
A nurse-administered, telephone-based disease management program delayed subsequent health care encounters, but had minimal impact on other outcomes.
心力衰竭是发病率和死亡率的常见且重要原因。疾病管理有望减少心力衰竭患者的住院需求并改善其生活质量,但此类项目疗效的实验数据有限。
总共151名因心力衰竭住院的患者被随机分为接受常规护理或由经过专门培训的护士进行定期电话随访两组,这些护士会促进自我管理并按照初级医师的处方进行基于指南的治疗。护士还会筛查患者是否有心力衰竭加重情况,并使用补充利尿剂或联系初级医师获取指示来进行处理。结局指标包括就医时间、死亡率、住院次数和费用、功能状态以及对护理的满意度。干预组患者的就医时间更长(风险比[HR]=0.67;95%置信区间[CI]0.47 - 0.96;P = 0.029),再次住院率(HR = 0.67;CI 0.46 - 0.99;P = 0.045)以及心力衰竭特异性再次住院率(HR = 0.62;CI 0.38 - 1.03;P = 0.063)。干预后前6个月的住院次数、住院天数和住院费用显著降低,但1年时未降低。该干预对功能状态、死亡率和护理满意度影响甚微。
一项由护士实施的、基于电话的疾病管理项目延迟了后续的医疗就诊,但对其他结局影响极小。