Misdrahi D, Delgado A, Bouju S, Comet D, Chiariny J-F
Pôle 347 de psychiatrie adulte, hôpital Charles-Perrens, 121, rue de la Béchade, 33076 Bordeaux cedex, France.
Encephale. 2013 May;39 Suppl 1:S8-14. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2012.03.005. Epub 2013 Mar 28.
Poor adherence is a major concern for the effectiveness of antipsychotic treatment in patients with schizophrenia. In particular, compliance problems constitute a poor prognostic factor for this disorder due to increasing risk of relapse and hospitalization. As maintaining antipsychotic therapy is a key element to prevent relapse, the use of depot preparations is therefore considered as a useful therapeutic option since it prevents covert non-adherence. When compared with neuroleptics, novel antipsychotic agents are also better tolerated by patients. In this study, the rationale for the use of long-acting injectable risperidone combining the benefits of novel antipsychotic agent and depot preparation is investigated in patients with psychosis. A secondary objective of the study is to assess the level of therapeutic adherence and to confirm the role of its key determinants.
An observational survey assessed the time and reasons to switch to long-acting risperidone in 1887 hospitalized and community-dwelling patients with psychosis (61.6% schizophrenia) defined by the CIM-10, and treated by 399 psychiatrists with oral risperidone for a recent acute episode. In a cross-sectional study performed under real-life conditions, treatment adherence was assessed by patients themselves using the Medication Adherence Questionnaire (MAQ) and therapeutic alliance was assessed by the 4-Point Alliance Scale (4-PAS). Psychiatrists assessed treatment acceptance using the Compliance Rating Scale (CRS), disease severity using the CGI, and insight using the G12 item from the Positive and Negative Syndrome Scale (PANSS).
In the population studied, disorder severity (CGI) was defined as "moderate to marked" in 67.7% and "severe or among the most severe" for 21.1%. Insight (PANSS G12) was defined as normal for 36.6% of patients, moderate for 34.8% and low for 28.6%. The mean time to medication switch was 8 weeks after the start of care of the acute episode. The two main reasons to start the long-acting injectable risperidone were related to non-compliance with oral antipsychotic treatment (92.4%) and intention to improve efficacy (86.4%). Maintenance of a good therapeutic alliance (70.3%) and treatment tolerability (54.6%) were also often cited. For psychiatrists, 41.6% of patients demonstrated reticence or active reluctance to treatment. Therapeutic compliance (MAQ) for oral medication before the long-acting injectable risperidone was started was estimated as "mild" for 53.1% (n=852) of patients. Poor adherence strongly correlated with low insight (P<0.001) and with a disorder estimated as "severe" (P<0.001). Therapeutic alliance was higher for patients with a better level of treatment acceptance assessed by psychiatrists (P<0.001) and with a higher compliance with MAQ estimated by patients (P<0.001). Therapeutic alliance was lower for patients with a disorder defined as "severe" (P<0.001) and with poor insight (P<0.001).
In this French survey, the two main reasons for psychiatrists to start long-acting injectable risperidone were related to non-compliance with oral antipsychotic treatment and with the desire to improve therapeutic efficacy. In accordance with results of previous studies, insight and therapeutic alliance were found to be associated with poor compliance. The main goal in the treatment of psychotic disorders is to obtain a functional remission and to reduce the incidence of relapse. Considering its improved efficiency and reduced dependence on patient compliance, the use of long-acting injectable risperidone is recommended as a useful therapeutic strategy.
依从性差是精神分裂症患者抗精神病药物治疗有效性的一个主要问题。特别是,依从性问题是该疾病预后不良的一个因素,因为复发和住院风险增加。由于维持抗精神病药物治疗是预防复发的关键因素,因此使用长效制剂被认为是一种有用的治疗选择,因为它可防止隐匿性不依从。与抗精神病药物相比,新型抗精神病药物也更易被患者耐受。在本研究中,对患有精神病的患者使用长效注射用利培酮结合新型抗精神病药物和长效制剂的益处的基本原理进行了研究。该研究的第二个目的是评估治疗依从性水平并确认其关键决定因素的作用。
一项观察性调查评估了1887例住院和社区居住的精神病患者(根据国际疾病分类第10版定义为61.6%为精神分裂症)转为长效利培酮的时间和原因,这些患者由399名精神科医生用口服利培酮治疗近期急性发作。在实际生活条件下进行的一项横断面研究中,患者使用药物依从性问卷(MAQ)自行评估治疗依从性,治疗联盟使用四点联盟量表(4-PAS)进行评估。精神科医生使用依从性评定量表(CRS)评估治疗接受度,使用临床总体印象量表(CGI)评估疾病严重程度,使用阳性和阴性症状量表(PANSS)中的G12项评估自知力。
在所研究的人群中,67.7%的患者疾病严重程度(CGI)被定义为“中度至显著”,21.1%为“严重或最严重”。36.6%的患者自知力(PANSS G12)被定义为正常,34.8%为中度,28.6%为低。转为药物治疗的平均时间为急性发作开始治疗后8周。开始使用长效注射用利培酮的两个主要原因与口服抗精神病药物治疗不依从(92.4%)和提高疗效的意愿(86.4%)有关。维持良好的治疗联盟(70.3%)和治疗耐受性(54.6%)也经常被提及。对于精神科医生来说,41.6%的患者表现出对治疗的沉默或积极抵触。在开始使用长效注射用利培酮之前,53.1%(n = 852)的患者口服药物的治疗依从性(MAQ)被估计为“轻度”。依从性差与自知力低(P < 0.001)和被估计为“严重”的疾病(P < 0.001)密切相关。精神科医生评估的治疗接受度较好的患者(P < 0.001)和患者估计的MAQ依从性较高的患者(P < 0.001)的治疗联盟更高。被定义为“严重”的疾病患者(P < 0.001)和自知力差的患者(P < 0.001)的治疗联盟较低。
在这项法国调查中,精神科医生开始使用长效注射用利培酮的两个主要原因与口服抗精神病药物治疗不依从和提高治疗效果的愿望有关。与先前研究结果一致,发现自知力和治疗联盟与依从性差有关。精神病性障碍治疗的主要目标是实现功能缓解并降低复发率。考虑到其提高的效率和对患者依从性的依赖性降低,建议使用长效注射用利培酮作为一种有用的治疗策略。