Pais Jeremy
Department of Sociology, University of Connecticut, 344 Mansfield Road, Unit 2068, Storrs, CT, 06269-2068, USA,
Demography. 2014 Oct;51(5):1729-53. doi: 10.1007/s13524-014-0330-9.
Cumulative structural disadvantage theory posits two major sources of endogenous selection in shaping racial health disparities: a race-based version of the theory anticipates a racially distinct selection process, whereas a social class-based version anticipates a racially similar process. To operationalize cumulative structural disadvantage, this study uses data from the 1979 National Longitudinal Survey of Youth in a Latent Class Analysis that demographically profiles health impairment trajectories. This analysis is used to examine the nature of selection as it relates to racial differences in the development of health impairments that are significant enough to hinder one's ability to work. The results provide no direct support for the race-based version of cumulative structural disadvantage theory. Instead, two key findings support the social class-based version of cumulative disadvantage theory. First, the functional form of the different health trajectories are invariant for whites and blacks, suggesting more racial similarly in the developmental process than anticipated by the race-based version of the theory. The extent of the racial disparity in the prevalences across the health impairment trajectories is, however, significant and noteworthy: nearly one-third of blacks (28 %) in the United States experience some form of impairment during their prime working years compared with 18.8 % of whites. Second, racial differences in childhood background mediate this racial health disparity through the indirect pathway of occupational attainment and through the direct pathway of early-life exposure to health-adverse environments. Thus, the selection of individuals into different health trajectories, based largely on childhood socioeconomic background, helps explain racial disparities in the development of health impairments.
该理论基于种族的版本预计会有一个种族上不同的选择过程,而基于社会阶层的版本预计会有一个种族上相似的过程。为了实施累积结构劣势,本研究使用了1979年全国青年纵向调查的数据,进行了潜在类别分析,从人口统计学角度描绘了健康损害轨迹。该分析用于检验选择的性质,因为它与健康损害发展中的种族差异相关,这些差异严重到足以阻碍一个人的工作能力。结果没有为累积结构劣势理论基于种族的版本提供直接支持。相反,两个关键发现支持了累积劣势理论基于社会阶层的版本。首先,不同健康轨迹的功能形式对白人和黑人来说是不变的,这表明在发展过程中的种族相似性比该理论基于种族的版本所预期的要高。然而,在整个健康损害轨迹中患病率的种族差异程度是显著且值得注意的:在美国,近三分之一的黑人(28%)在其黄金工作年龄经历了某种形式的损害,而白人的这一比例为18.8%。其次,童年背景的种族差异通过职业获得的间接途径和早年接触对健康不利环境的直接途径介导了这种种族健康差异。因此,很大程度上基于童年社会经济背景将个体选择到不同的健康轨迹中,有助于解释健康损害发展中的种族差异。