Wrycza Tomasz F, Missov Trifon I, Baudisch Annette
Max Planck Institute for Demographic Research, Rostock, Germany.
Max Planck Institute for Demographic Research, Rostock, Germany; Institute of Sociology and Demography, University of Rostock, Germany.
PLoS One. 2015 Mar 24;10(3):e0119163. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0119163. eCollection 2015.
In Biodemography, aging is typically measured and compared based on aging rates. We argue that this approach may be misleading, because it confounds the time aspect with the mere change aspect of aging. To disentangle these aspects, here we utilize a time-standardized framework and, instead of aging rates, suggest the shape of aging as a novel and valuable alternative concept for comparative aging research. The concept of shape captures the direction and degree of change in the force of mortality over age, which—on a demographic level—reflects aging. We 1) provide a list of shape properties that are desirable from a theoretical perspective, 2) suggest several demographically meaningful and non-parametric candidate measures to quantify shape, and 3) evaluate performance of these measures based on the list of properties as well as based on an illustrative analysis of a simple dataset. The shape measures suggested here aim to provide a general means to classify aging patterns independent of any particular mortality model and independent of any species-specific time-scale. Thereby they support systematic comparative aging research across different species or between populations of the same species under different conditions and constitute an extension of the toolbox available to comparative research in Biodemography.
在生物人口统计学中,衰老通常是根据衰老速率来衡量和比较的。我们认为这种方法可能会产生误导,因为它将时间因素与衰老的单纯变化因素混为一谈。为了厘清这些因素,我们在这里使用了一个时间标准化框架,并且建议用衰老的形状作为比较衰老研究中一个新颖且有价值的替代概念,而不是使用衰老速率。形状的概念捕捉了死亡率随年龄变化的方向和程度,在人口统计学层面上,这反映了衰老。我们:1)提供了一份从理论角度来看理想的形状属性列表;2)建议了几种具有人口统计学意义的非参数候选度量来量化形状;3)根据属性列表以及对一个简单数据集的说明性分析来评估这些度量的性能。这里建议的形状度量旨在提供一种通用方法,用于独立于任何特定死亡率模型以及独立于任何特定物种时间尺度来对衰老模式进行分类。从而,它们支持跨不同物种或同一物种在不同条件下的种群之间进行系统的比较衰老研究,并构成了生物人口统计学比较研究可用工具箱的扩展。