Bonati Ulrike, Hafner Patricia, Schädelin Sabine, Schmid Maurice, Naduvilekoot Devasia Arjith, Schroeder Jonas, Zuesli Stephanie, Pohlman Urs, Neuhaus Cornelia, Klein Andrea, Sinnreich Michael, Haas Tanja, Gloor Monika, Bieri Oliver, Fischmann Arne, Fischer Dirk
University of Basel Children's Hospital, Division of Neuropaediatrics, Spitalstrasse 33, Postfach, Basel 4031, Switzerland; University of Basel Hospital, Department of Neurology, Petersgraben 4, Basel 4031, Switzerland.
University of Basel Hospital, Department of Neurology, Petersgraben 4, Basel 4031, Switzerland.
Neuromuscul Disord. 2015 Sep;25(9):679-85. doi: 10.1016/j.nmd.2015.05.006. Epub 2015 Jun 4.
In muscular dystrophies quantitative muscle MRI (qMRI) detects disease progression more sensitively than clinical scores. This prospective one year observational study compared qMRI with clinical scores in Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD) to investigate if qMRI can serve as a surrogate outcome measure in clinical trials. In 20 DMD patients the motor function measure (MFM) total and subscores (D1-D3) were done for physical examination, and the fat fraction (MFF) of thigh muscle qMRI was obtained using the two-point Dixon method. Effect sizes (ES) were calculated for all measures. Sample size estimation (SS) was done modelling assumed treatment effects. Ambulant patients <7 years at inclusion improved in the MFM total and D1 score (ES 1.1 and 1.0). Ambulant patients >7 years (highest ES in the MFM D1 subscore (1.2)), and non-ambulant patients (highest ES in the total MFM score (0.7)) worsened. In comparison the ES of QMRI was much larger, e.g. SS estimations for qMRI data were up to 17 fold smaller compared to the MFM total score and up to 7 fold to the D1 subscore, respectively. QMRI shows pathophysiological changes in DMD and might serve as a surrogate outcome measure in clinical trials.
在肌肉营养不良症中,定量肌肉磁共振成像(qMRI)比临床评分更能敏感地检测疾病进展。这项为期一年的前瞻性观察研究比较了杜氏肌营养不良症(DMD)患者的qMRI与临床评分,以调查qMRI是否可作为临床试验中的替代结局指标。对20例DMD患者进行了运动功能测量(MFM)的总分及分项评分(D1-D3)以进行体格检查,并使用两点狄克逊法获得大腿肌肉qMRI的脂肪分数(MFF)。计算所有测量指标的效应量(ES)。进行样本量估计(SS),对假定的治疗效果进行建模。纳入时年龄小于7岁的能行走患者的MFM总分及D1评分有所改善(ES分别为1.1和1.0)。年龄大于7岁的能行走患者(MFM D1分项评分的ES最高,为1.2)和不能行走的患者(MFM总分的ES最高,为0.7)病情恶化。相比之下,qMRI的ES要大得多,例如,qMRI数据的SS估计分别比MFM总分小17倍,比D1分项评分小7倍。qMRI显示了DMD的病理生理变化,可能作为临床试验中的替代结局指标。