Johnson Jacinta L, Kwok Yuen H, Sumracki Nicole M, Swift James E, Hutchinson Mark R, Johnson Kirk, Williams Desmond B, Tuke Jonathon, Rolan Paul E
Discipline of Pharmacology, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, Australia.
Discipline of Physiology, University of Adelaide, Adelaide, Australia.
Headache. 2015 Oct;55(9):1192-208. doi: 10.1111/head.12655. Epub 2015 Sep 14.
Medication overuse headache (MOH) is a condition bordering between a chronic pain condition and a substance dependence disorder. Activation of immunocompetent glial cells in the central nervous system has been linked to both pathological pain and drug addiction/reward. Preclinically, ibudilast attenuates glial activation and is able to reduce neuropathic pain and markers of substance dependence. We therefore hypothesized ibudilast would reduce headache burden and opioid analgesic requirements in patients with opioid overuse headache.
To determine if treatment with ibudilast provides a greater reduction in headache index than placebo in MOH patients consuming opioids.
Participants with MOH who were using opioids were randomized via computer-generated code to ibudilast 40 mg or placebo twice daily for 8 weeks in a double-blind, parallel groups study. Before randomization participants completed a 4-week baseline headache diary. During treatment, headache diary data collection continued and participants attended 4 study visits during which quantitative sensory testing was performed. Blood samples for immune biomarker analyses were collected before and after treatment in a subgroup of participants.
Thirty-four participants were randomized, 13 of 15 randomized to ibudilast and 17 of 19 randomized to placebo completed treatment. Ibudilast was generally well-tolerated with mild, transient nausea reported as the most common adverse event (66.7% vs 10.5% in placebo group). Results are shown as mean (SD). At the end of treatment no differences in the primary outcome average daily headache index (placebo 62 [44] vs ibudilast 77 [72] groups, difference -15, CI -65 to 35 h × numerical rating scale), or secondary outcomes headache frequency (placebo 23 [8.1] vs ibudilast 24.5 [6.2], difference -1.5, CI -7.7 to 4.8 days/month) and opioid intake (placebo 20.6 [43] vs ibudilast 19 [24.3], difference 1.6, CI -31.5 to 34.8 mg morphine equivalent) were observed between placebo and ibudilast groups.
Using the current dosing regimen, ibudilast does not improve headache or reduce opioid use in patients with MOH without mandated opioid withdrawal. However, it would be of interest to determine in future trials if ibudilast is able to improve ease of withdrawal during a forced opioid down-titration when incorporated into an MOH detoxification program.
药物过量使用性头痛(MOH)是一种介于慢性疼痛病症和物质依赖障碍之间的疾病。中枢神经系统中具有免疫活性的神经胶质细胞的激活与病理性疼痛以及药物成瘾/奖赏均有关联。临床前研究表明,异丁司特可减轻神经胶质细胞激活,并能够减轻神经性疼痛以及物质依赖的标志物。因此,我们推测异丁司特可减轻阿片类药物过量使用性头痛患者的头痛负担并降低阿片类镇痛药的需求量。
确定在使用阿片类药物的MOH患者中,异丁司特治疗是否比安慰剂能更大程度地降低头痛指数。
在一项双盲、平行组研究中,将正在使用阿片类药物的MOH参与者通过计算机生成的编码随机分为两组,分别每日两次服用40mg异丁司特或安慰剂,持续8周。在随机分组前,参与者完成一份为期4周的基线头痛日记。在治疗期间,继续收集头痛日记数据,参与者参加4次研究访视,期间进行定量感觉测试。在一部分参与者亚组中,于治疗前后采集血样用于免疫生物标志物分析。
34名参与者被随机分组,随机分配至异丁司特组的15人中有13人、随机分配至安慰剂组的19人中有17人完成了治疗。异丁司特总体耐受性良好,报告的最常见不良事件为轻度、短暂性恶心(异丁司特组为66.7%,安慰剂组为10.5%)。结果以均值(标准差)表示。在治疗结束时,安慰剂组和异丁司特组在主要结局平均每日头痛指数(安慰剂组62[标准差44],异丁司特组77[标准差72],差值-15,可信区间-65至35小时×数字评分量表)、次要结局头痛频率(安慰剂组23[标准差8.1],异丁司特组24.5[标准差6.2],差值-1.5,可信区间-7.7至4.8天/月)和阿片类药物摄入量(安慰剂组20.6[标准差43],异丁司特组19[标准差24.3],差值1.6,可信区间-31.5至34.8毫克吗啡当量)方面均未观察到差异。
采用当前给药方案,在未强制停用阿片类药物的MOH患者中,异丁司特并不能改善头痛或减少阿片类药物的使用。然而,在未来试验中确定将异丁司特纳入MOH解毒方案时是否能够在强制减少阿片类药物剂量过程中提高戒断的 ease of withdrawal(此处原文可能有误,推测是ease of withdrawal,可译为“戒断的 ease of withdrawal(此处原文可能有误)”,推测是“戒断的易感性”之类意思,但因原文可能错误暂无法准确翻译)将是有意义的。