British Columbia Centre on Substance Use, 400-1045 Howe Street, Vancouver, British Columbia, V6Z 2A9, Canada.
Western Aboriginal Harm Reduction Society, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada.
Harm Reduct J. 2020 Mar 24;17(1):19. doi: 10.1186/s12954-020-00366-3.
In Canada, and elsewhere, indigenous peoples who use illicit drugs and/or alcohol (IPWUID/A) commonly experience vulnerability and a disproportionate burden of harm related to substance use. In Vancouver, Canada, there are concerns that inequitable access, retention, and post treatment care within substance use treatment programs may exacerbate these harms. This study sought to understand the policies and practices with the potential to produce inequities and vulnerabilities for IPWUID/A in substance use treatment, situate the vulnerabilities of IPWUID/A in substance use treatment within the context of wider structural vulnerability of IPWUID/A, and generate recommendations for culturally safe treatment options.
This research employed a qualitative indigenous-led community-based approach using the indigenous methodology of talking circles to explore experiences with substance use treatment. Under the participatory research framework, community researchers led the study design, data collection, and analysis. Talking circles elicited peers' experiences of substance use treatment and were audio-recorded and transcribed.
The talking circles identified three key themes that illustrated the experiences of IPWUID/A when accessing substance use treatment: (a) barriers to accessing detox and substance use treatment; (b) incompatible and culturally inappropriate structure, policies, and procedures within treatment programs, such as forced Christianity within treatment settings; and (c) the importance of culturally relevant, peer-led substance use treatment programming.
Our work demonstrates that some IPWUID/A have limited access to or retention in mainstream treatment due to excessive waiting times, strict rules, and lack of cultural appropriate care while in treatment. However, IPWUID/A narratives revealed strategies that can improve IPWUID/A access and experiences, including those informed by the diverse perspectives of IPWUID/A and those that include trauma-informed and culturally safe practices.
在加拿大和其他地方,使用非法药物和/或酒精的土著人民(IPWUID/A)通常容易受到伤害,并且与药物使用相关的伤害负担不成比例。在加拿大温哥华,人们担心药物使用治疗方案中存在获得机会、保留和治疗后护理方面的不平等,这可能会加剧这些伤害。本研究旨在了解可能导致 IPWUID/A 在药物使用治疗中出现不平等和脆弱性的政策和做法,将 IPWUID/A 在药物使用治疗中的脆弱性置于 IPWUID/A 更广泛的结构性脆弱性背景下,并为文化安全的治疗选择提出建议。
本研究采用了定性的、以社区为基础的、以土著为导向的方法,使用土著的谈话圈方法来探讨药物使用治疗方面的经验。在参与式研究框架下,社区研究人员主导了研究设计、数据收集和分析。谈话圈引出了同行在药物使用治疗方面的经验,并对其进行了录音和转录。
谈话圈确定了三个关键主题,说明了 IPWUID/A 获得药物使用治疗时的体验:(a)进入戒毒和药物使用治疗的障碍;(b)治疗方案中存在不兼容和不适合文化的结构、政策和程序,例如治疗环境中的强制基督教;(c)文化相关的、由同行领导的药物使用治疗方案的重要性。
我们的工作表明,由于等待时间过长、严格的规定和缺乏文化适宜的护理,一些 IPWUID/A 获得主流治疗的机会有限,或在治疗期间无法保留在治疗中。然而,IPWUID/A 的叙述揭示了一些可以改善 IPWUID/A 获得治疗机会和体验的策略,包括那些由 IPWUID/A 的不同观点所启发的策略,以及那些包括创伤知情和文化安全实践的策略。