Chen Tianhua, Shang Changjing, Su Pan, Keravnou-Papailiou Elpida, Zhao Yitian, Antoniou Grigoris, Shen Qiang
Department of Computer Science, School of Computing and Engineering, University of Huddersfield, Huddersfield, UK.
Department of Computer Science, Faculty of Business and Physical Science, Aberystwyth University, Aberystwyth, UK.
Artif Intell Med. 2021 Jan;111:101986. doi: 10.1016/j.artmed.2020.101986. Epub 2020 Nov 12.
Apart from the need for superior accuracy, healthcare applications of intelligent systems also demand the deployment of interpretable machine learning models which allow clinicians to interrogate and validate extracted medical knowledge. Fuzzy rule-based models are generally considered interpretable that are able to reflect the associations between medical conditions and associated symptoms, through the use of linguistic if-then statements. Systems built on top of fuzzy sets are of particular appealing to medical applications since they enable the tolerance of vague and imprecise concepts that are often embedded in medical entities such as symptom description and test results. They facilitate an approximate reasoning framework which mimics human reasoning and supports the linguistic delivery of medical expertise often expressed in statements such as 'weight low' or 'glucose level high' while describing symptoms. This paper proposes an approach by performing data-driven learning of accurate and interpretable fuzzy rule bases for clinical decision support. The approach starts with the generation of a crisp rule base through a decision tree learning mechanism, capable of capturing simple rule structures. The crisp rule base is then transformed into a fuzzy rule base, which forms the input to the framework of adaptive network-based fuzzy inference system (ANFIS), thereby further optimising the parameters of both rule antecedents and consequents. Experimental studies on popular medical data benchmarks demonstrate that the proposed work is able to learn compact rule bases involving simple rule antecedents, with statistically better or comparable performance to those achieved by state-of-the-art fuzzy classifiers.
除了需要卓越的准确性外,智能系统在医疗保健领域的应用还要求部署可解释的机器学习模型,以便临床医生能够审视和验证提取的医学知识。基于模糊规则的模型通常被认为是可解释的,通过使用语言上的“如果……那么……”语句,能够反映病症与相关症状之间的关联。基于模糊集构建的系统对医疗应用特别有吸引力,因为它们能够容忍模糊和不精确的概念,这些概念常常嵌入在诸如症状描述和测试结果等医学实体中。它们促进了一种近似推理框架,该框架模仿人类推理,并支持在描述症状时常用“体重低”或“血糖水平高”等语句进行医学专业知识的语言表达。本文提出了一种通过数据驱动学习准确且可解释的模糊规则库来支持临床决策的方法。该方法首先通过决策树学习机制生成一个清晰的规则库,该机制能够捕捉简单的规则结构。然后将清晰的规则库转换为模糊规则库,作为基于自适应网络的模糊推理系统(ANFIS)框架的输入,从而进一步优化规则前件和后件的参数。对流行医学数据基准的实验研究表明,所提出的工作能够学习包含简单规则前件的紧凑规则库,在统计性能上优于或与现有最先进的模糊分类器相当。