Pearson Andrew Dj, Rossig Claudia, Mackall Crystal, Shah Nirali N, Baruchel Andre, Reaman Gregory, Ricafort Rosanna, Heenen Delphine, Bassan Abraham, Berntgen Michael, Bird Nick, Bleickardt Eric, Bouchkouj Najat, Bross Peter, Brownstein Carrie, Cohen Sarah Beaussant, de Rojas Teresa, Ehrlich Lori, Fox Elizabeth, Gottschalk Stephen, Hanssens Linda, Hawkins Douglas S, Horak Ivan D, Taylor Danielle H, Johnson Courtney, Karres Dominik, Ligas Franca, Ludwinski Donna, Mamonkin Maksim, Marshall Lynley, Masouleh Behzad K, Matloub Yousif, Maude Shannon, McDonough Joe, Minard-Colin Veronique, Norga Koen, Nysom Karsten, Pappo Alberto, Pearce Laura, Pieters Rob, Pule Martin, Quintás-Cardama Alfonso, Richardson Nick, Schüßler-Lenz Martina, Scobie Nicole, Sersch Martina A, Smith Malcolm A, Sterba Jaroslav, Tasian Sarah K, Weigel Brenda, Weiner Susan L, Zwaan Christian Michel, Lesa Giovanni, Vassal Gilles
ACCELERATE, Europe.
University Children´s Hospital Muenster, Pediatric Hematology and Oncology, Germany.
Eur J Cancer. 2022 Jan;160:112-133. doi: 10.1016/j.ejca.2021.10.016. Epub 2021 Nov 25.
The seventh multi-stakeholder Paediatric Strategy Forum focused on chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T-cells for children and adolescents with cancer. The development of CAR T-cells for patients with haematological malignancies, especially B-cell precursor acute lymphoblastic leukaemia (BCP-ALL), has been spectacular. However, currently, there are scientific, clinical and logistical challenges for use of CAR T-cells in BCP-ALL and other paediatric malignancies, particularly in acute myeloid leukaemia (AML), lymphomas and solid tumours. The aims of the Forum were to summarise the current landscape of CAR T-cell therapy development in paediatrics, too identify current challenges and future directions, with consideration of other immune effector modalities and ascertain the best strategies to accelerate their development and availability to children. Although the effect is of limited duration in about half of the patients, anti-CD19 CAR T-cells produce high response rates in relapsed/refractory BCP-ALL and this has highlighted previously unknown mechanisms of relapse. CAR T-cell treatment as first- or second-line therapy could also potentially benefit patients whose disease has high-risk features associated with relapse and failure of conventional therapies. Identifying patients with very early and early relapse in whom CAR T-cell therapy may replace haematopoietic stem cell transplantation and be definitive therapy versus those in whom it provides a more effective bridge to haematopoietic stem cell transplantation is a very high priority. Development of approaches to improve persistence, either by improving T cell fitness or using more humanised/fully humanised products and co-targeting of multiple antigens to prevent antigen escape, could potentially further optimise therapy. Many differences exist between paediatric B-cell non-Hodgkin lymphomas (B-NHL) and BCP-ALL. In view of the very small patient numbers with relapsed lymphoma, careful prioritisation is needed to evaluate CAR T-cells in children with Burkitt lymphoma, primary mediastinal B cell lymphoma and other NHL subtypes. Combination trials of alternative targets to CD19 (CD20 or CD22) should also be explored as a priority to improve efficacy in this population. Development of CD30 CAR T-cell immunotherapy strategies in patients with relapsed/refractory Hodgkin lymphoma will likely be most efficiently accomplished by joint paediatric and adult trials. CAR T-cell approaches are early in development for AML and T-ALL, given the unique challenges of successful immunotherapy actualisation in these diseases. At this time, CD33 and CD123 appear to be the most universal targets in AML and CD7 in T-ALL. The results of ongoing or planned first-in-human studies are required to facilitate further understanding. There are promising early results in solid tumours, particularly with GD2 targeting cell therapies in neuroblastoma and central nervous system gliomas that represent significant unmet clinical needs. Further understanding of biology is critical to success. The comparative benefits of autologous versus allogeneic CAR T-cells, T-cells engineered with T cell receptors T-cells engineered with T cell receptor fusion constructs, CAR Natural Killer (NK)-cell products, bispecific T-cell engager antibodies and antibody-drug conjugates require evaluation in paediatric malignancies. Early and proactive academia and multi-company engagement are mandatory to advance cellular immunotherapies in paediatric oncology. Regulatory advice should be sought very early in the design and preparation of clinical trials of innovative medicines, for which regulatory approval may ultimately be sought. Aligning strategic, scientific, regulatory, health technology and funding requirements from the inception of a clinical trial is especially important as these are very expensive therapies. The model for drug development for cell therapy in paediatric oncology could also involve a 'later stage handoff' to industry after early development in academic hands. Finally, and very importantly, strategies must evolve to ensure appropriate ease of access for children who need and could potentially benefit from these therapies.
第七届多方利益相关者儿科战略论坛聚焦于针对患癌儿童和青少年的嵌合抗原受体(CAR)T细胞。针对血液系统恶性肿瘤患者,尤其是B细胞前体急性淋巴细胞白血病(BCP-ALL)患者的CAR T细胞研发取得了显著进展。然而,目前在BCP-ALL和其他儿科恶性肿瘤,特别是急性髓系白血病(AML)、淋巴瘤和实体瘤中使用CAR T细胞存在科学、临床和后勤方面的挑战。该论坛的目的是总结儿科CAR T细胞疗法研发的现状,确定当前的挑战和未来方向,同时考虑其他免疫效应方式,并确定加速其研发以及让儿童能够使用这些疗法的最佳策略。尽管约一半患者的疗效持续时间有限,但抗CD19 CAR T细胞在复发/难治性BCP-ALL中产生了高缓解率,这凸显了此前未知的复发机制。CAR T细胞治疗作为一线或二线疗法也可能使那些疾病具有与传统疗法复发和失败相关的高危特征的患者受益。确定哪些早期和极早期复发的患者中CAR T细胞疗法可以替代造血干细胞移植并成为确定性疗法,以及哪些患者中它能为造血干细胞移植提供更有效的桥梁,这是非常重要的优先事项。通过改善T细胞健康状况或使用更人源化/完全人源化的产品以及共同靶向多种抗原以防止抗原逃逸来提高持久性的方法的开发,可能会进一步优化治疗。儿科B细胞非霍奇金淋巴瘤(B-NHL)和BCP-ALL之间存在许多差异。鉴于复发淋巴瘤患者数量极少,需要仔细确定优先次序,以评估伯基特淋巴瘤、原发性纵隔B细胞淋巴瘤和其他NHL亚型儿童中的CAR T细胞。作为优先事项,还应探索针对CD19(CD20或CD22)的替代靶点的联合试验,以提高该人群的疗效。复发/难治性霍奇金淋巴瘤患者中CD30 CAR T细胞免疫疗法策略的开发可能通过儿科和成人联合试验最有效地完成。鉴于在这些疾病中成功实现免疫疗法存在独特挑战,CAR T细胞方法在AML和T-ALL的研发尚处于早期阶段。目前,CD33和CD123似乎是AML中最通用的靶点,CD7是T-ALL中的靶点。需要正在进行或计划中的首次人体研究结果以促进进一步了解。实体瘤有一些有前景的早期结果,特别是在神经母细胞瘤和中枢神经系统胶质瘤中针对GD2的细胞疗法,这些疾病代表了重大的未满足临床需求。对生物学的进一步了解对成功至关重要。自体与异体CAR T细胞、用T细胞受体工程改造的T细胞、用T细胞受体融合构建体工程改造的T细胞、CAR自然杀伤(NK)细胞产品、双特异性T细胞衔接抗体和抗体药物偶联物的相对益处需要在儿科恶性肿瘤中进行评估。早期和积极的学术界与多家公司合作对于推进儿科肿瘤学中的细胞免疫疗法是必不可少的。在设计和准备创新药物临床试验时应尽早寻求监管建议,最终可能会寻求监管批准。从临床试验一开始就使战略、科学、监管、卫生技术和资金需求保持一致尤为重要,因为这些疗法非常昂贵。儿科肿瘤学中细胞疗法的药物研发模式也可能涉及在学术机构进行早期开发后向行业进行“后期交接”。最后,非常重要的是,必须制定策略以确保有需要且可能从这些疗法中受益的儿童能够方便地获得治疗。