Department of Global Health and Social Medicine, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, USA.
Bond University, Gold Coast, QLD, Australia.
World J Surg. 2023 Jun;47(6):1419-1425. doi: 10.1007/s00268-023-06958-x. Epub 2023 Mar 8.
In 2021, a 7.2 magnitude earthquake struck Haiti resulting in a surge of orthopaedic trauma requiring immediate surgical treatment. Safe and efficient operative management of orthopaedic trauma injuries requires intraoperative fluoroscopy through C-arm machines. The Haitian Health Network (HHN) received a philanthropic donation of three C-arm machines and considered an analytical tool may guide efficacious placement of those machines. The study objective was to develop and apply a clinical needs and hospital readiness measuring tool relevant to C-arm machines, which may guide decision-makers, such as HHN, in response to an emergency situation with a surge in need for orthopaedic treatment.
An online survey to assess surgical volume and capacity was created and then completed by a senior surgeon or hospital administrator based at hospitals within the HHN. Multiple-choice and free-text answer data were collected and classified into five categories: staff, space, stuff, systems, and surgical capacity. Each hospital received a final score out of 100, calculated by equal weighting of each category.
Ten out of twelve hospitals completed the survey. The average weighted score for the staff category was 10.2 (SD 5.12), the space category was 13.1 (SD 4.09), the stuff category was 15.6 (SD 2.56), the systems category was 12.25 (SD 6.50), and the surgical capacity category was 9.5 (SD 6.47). The average final hospital scores ranged from 29.5 to 83.0.
This analysis tool provided data as to the clinical demand and capabilities of hospitals within the HHN to receive a C-arm machine and reaffirmed the critical need for more C-arms in Haiti. This methodology may be utilised by other health systems to provide data to distribute orthopaedic trauma equipment, which would benefit communities during periods of surge capacity, such as natural disasters.
2021 年,海地发生 7.2 级地震,导致大量骨科创伤需要立即进行手术治疗。安全有效的骨科创伤处理需要通过 C 臂机进行术中透视。海地健康网络(HHN)收到了一项慈善捐赠,获得了三台 C 臂机,并认为分析工具可能有助于有效地放置这些机器。本研究旨在开发并应用一种与 C 臂机相关的临床需求和医院准备情况的衡量工具,这可能有助于决策者(如 HHN)在骨科治疗需求激增的紧急情况下做出决策。
创建了一个在线调查,以评估手术量和容量,然后由 HHN 内的医院的一名资深外科医生或医院管理人员完成。收集了多项选择题和自由文本答案,并将其分为五类:人员、空间、设备、系统和手术容量。每家医院的最终得分为 100 分,每个类别的权重相等。
12 家医院中有 10 家完成了调查。人员类别加权平均得分为 10.2(SD 5.12),空间类别为 13.1(SD 4.09),设备类别为 15.6(SD 2.56),系统类别为 12.25(SD 6.50),手术容量类别为 9.5(SD 6.47)。医院的平均最终得分范围为 29.5 至 83.0。
该分析工具提供了 HHN 内医院接收 C 臂机的临床需求和能力的数据,并再次确认了海地急需更多 C 臂机。这种方法可以被其他卫生系统用来提供分配骨科创伤设备的数据,这将在能力激增期间(如自然灾害)使社区受益。