Ali Sunjida Binta, Chakma Nantu, Islam Md Saimul, Amzad Raian, Khan Md Lftakhar Hassan, Aziulla Md, Momtaz Tanisha, Azad Abul Kalam, Babar Zaheer-Ud-Din, Naheed Aliya
Initiative for Non-Communicable Diseases, Health System and Population Studies Division, International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Dhaka, Bangladesh.
Management Sciences for Health (MSH), Dhaka, Bangladesh.
Front Pharmacol. 2023 Jul 12;14:1139632. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2023.1139632. eCollection 2023.
Training improves dispensing behavior of drug dispensers in low- and middle-income countries. Between 2018 and 2020, a total of 5,059 Grade C pharmacists, who completed a 3-month training course for availing a "Grade C pharmacist certificate" were trained on Good Pharmacy Practice (GPP) in 11 districts in Bangladesh by Management Sciences for Health (MSH) under Better Health in Bangladesh (BHB) project. We assessed the impact of GPP among trained Grade C pharmacists under the BHB project compared to those who did not receive GPP training under the BHB project (non-trained), and explored the major challenges towards achieving GPP. We created a database of trained Grade C pharmacists provided by MSH and randomly selected the trained Grade C pharmacists for recruitment following consent. We created another database of the non-trained Grade C pharmacist who were deployed within a 1-km radius of a trained Grade C pharmacist, and randomly recruited one non-trained against one trained Grade C pharmacist. A semi structured questionnaire was administered to obtain information about knowledge of GPP, including guidelines of dispensing medicines, temperature maintenance, medicine storage, counseling customers and labeling medicines. Dispensing behavior was directly observed following a structured tool. Chi-square test (for categorical variables) and independent sample t-tests (for continuous variables) were applied for comparison between the trained and the non-trained Grade C pharmacists. A logistic regression model was applied to explore an association between knowledge and practice between the two groups. Between February and March 2021, 220 trained and 220 non-trained Grade C pharmacists were recruited. Mean age (SD) of the participants was 41 years (10.5) and 98.4% were male. Compared to the non-trained, the trained Grade C pharmacists had better knowledge about the guidelines of dispensing medicines (97.7% vs 89.5%, < 0.001), temperature maintenance (91.8% vs 45.5%, = 0.001), medicine storage (92.3% vs 40.5%, = 0.001) counseling customers (99.5% vs 92.3%, < .001) and labeling medicines (91.0% vs 80%, < 0.001). General dispensing behavior was observed to be better among the trained than the non-trained with labeling of medicines (63.2% vs 53.4%, = 0.038), counseling customers (39.1% vs 28.6%, = 0.021) and using a room thermometer for maintaining ambient temperature in the medicine shops (56.8% vs26.8%, < 0.001). Bad behavior of the customers (39.5%) and lack of GPP knowledge among Grade C pharmacists (28.6%) were recognized to be challenges towards achieving GPP in Bangladesh. Training led to better knowledge and practices about dispensing medicines among Grade C pharmacists in Bangladesh. Periodic training may promote achieving GPP in Bangladesh.
培训可改善低收入和中等收入国家药剂师的配药行为。2018年至2020年期间,管理科学健康组织(MSH)在孟加拉国“更健康的孟加拉国”(BHB)项目下,为孟加拉国11个地区的5059名C级药剂师提供了为期3个月的培训课程,使其获得“C级药剂师证书”,培训内容包括良好药房实践(GPP)。我们评估了BHB项目中接受GPP培训的C级药剂师与未接受GPP培训的C级药剂师(未培训者)相比GPP所产生的影响,并探讨了实现GPP面临的主要挑战。我们创建了一个由MSH提供的接受培训的C级药剂师数据库,并在征得同意后随机选择接受培训的C级药剂师进行招募。我们创建了另一个未培训的C级药剂师数据库,这些药剂师被部署在接受培训的C级药剂师半径1公里范围内,并针对每一名接受培训的C级药剂师随机招募一名未培训的C级药剂师。通过一份半结构化问卷来获取有关GPP知识的信息,包括药品调配指南、温度维持、药品储存、为顾客提供咨询以及药品标签等方面。按照一个结构化工具直接观察配药行为。采用卡方检验(用于分类变量)和独立样本t检验(用于连续变量)对接受培训和未接受培训的C级药剂师进行比较。应用逻辑回归模型来探究两组之间知识与实践的关联。在2021年2月至3月期间,招募了220名接受培训的C级药剂师和220名未接受培训的C级药剂师。参与者的平均年龄(标准差)为41岁(10.5),98.4%为男性。与未接受培训者相比,接受培训的C级药剂师在药品调配指南(97.7%对89.5%,P<0.001)、温度维持(91.8%对45.5%,P = 0.001)、药品储存(92.3%对40.5%,P = 0.001)、为顾客提供咨询(99.5%对92.3%,P<0.001)以及药品标签(91.0%对80%,P<0.001)方面有更好的知识。观察发现,接受培训者在药品标签(63.2%对53.4%,P = 0.038)、为顾客提供咨询(39.1%对28.6%P = 0.021)以及在药店使用室内温度计维持环境温度(56.8%对26.8%,P<0.001)方面的总体配药行为比未接受培训者更好。顾客的不良行为(39.5%)和C级药剂师缺乏GPP知识(28.6%)被认为是孟加拉国实现GPP面临的挑战。培训使孟加拉国C级药剂师在药品调配方面有了更好的知识和实践。定期培训可能会促进孟加拉国实现GPP。