British Columbia Centre on Substance Use, 717 East Hastings St., Vancouver, BC, V6Z 2A9, Canada; Interdisciplinary Studies Graduate Program, University of British Columbia, 170-6371 Crescent Road, Vancouver, BC, V6T 1Z2, Canada.
School of Nursing, University of British Columbia, T201-2211 Wesbrook Mall, Vancouver, BC, V6T 2B5, Canada.
Soc Sci Med. 2024 May;348:116708. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2024.116708. Epub 2024 Mar 20.
As part of the response to Canada's worsening overdose crisis driven by a toxic, adulterated drug supply, there has been increased attention to and expansion of drug treatment, options, including injectable opioid agonist treatment (iOAT). iOAT typically involves the, witnessed daily injection of opioids under healthcare provider supervision. There is a robust, evidence base on iOAT; however, there has been less focus on how people engage with this; treatment outside of clinical trials. This paper examines how people engage with iOAT programs, in expanded treatment settings in Canada, focusing on how the broader socio-structural context, shapes patient subjectivities in treatment.
This study draws on critical ethnographic and community-based research approaches, conducted with people accessing four iOAT programs in Vancouver's Downtown Eastside; neighbourhood from May 2018 to November 2019. Data included in-depth baseline and followup, interviews and approximately 50 h of observation fieldwork conducted in one iOAT, program and with a subsample of participants in the surrounding neighbourhood. Analysis, leveraged the concepts of biological citizenship and structural vulnerability.
This analysis characterized three narrative frames-regular long-term engagers, pain, patients, and sporadic and short-term engagers-through in-depth case presentations of participants with distinct types of engagement with iOAT programs. Participants within these, narrative frames described a dominant form of iOAT citizenship, an autonomous patient who, regularly engages in treatment and avoids pleasure. However, structural vulnerabilities, including, homelessness and housing instability, entrenched poverty, criminal-legal system engagement, and unmanaged pain, shaped the ability of participants to make claims to this normative model of citizenship.
This study examined how structural vulnerabilities impact people's construction and ability to make iOAT citizenship claims. Findings point to the need for changes within and outside of iOAT programs, such as lower threshold treatment models, improved social services (e.g., secure housing), and pain management support.
作为应对加拿大日益恶化的阿片类药物过量危机的措施之一,加拿大加大了对毒品治疗的关注和投入,包括注射类阿片类药物激动剂治疗(IOAT)。IOAT 通常涉及在医疗保健提供者的监督下,每天见证注射阿片类药物。IOAT 有一个强大的证据基础,但人们对如何在临床试验之外参与治疗的关注较少。本文考察了在加拿大扩大治疗环境下,人们如何参与 IOAT 项目,重点关注更广泛的社会结构背景如何影响治疗中的患者主体性。
这项研究借鉴了批判民族志和社区基础研究方法,于 2018 年 5 月至 2019 年 11 月期间,在温哥华唐人街的四个 IOAT 项目中,对接触这些项目的人进行了研究。数据包括深度基线和随访访谈,以及在一个 IOAT 项目中进行的大约 50 小时的观察实地工作,以及在周围社区中对部分参与者进行的观察。分析利用了生物公民身份和结构脆弱性的概念。
通过对具有不同类型 IOAT 项目参与方式的参与者的深入案例介绍,本分析将参与者分为三个叙述框架——长期固定参与者、疼痛患者和偶尔短期参与者。这些叙述框架中的参与者描述了一种占主导地位的 IOAT 公民身份形式,即一个定期参与治疗并避免愉悦的自主患者。然而,包括无家可归和住房不稳定、根深蒂固的贫困、刑事法律系统参与以及未得到管理的疼痛在内的结构性脆弱性,影响了参与者提出这种规范性公民身份模式的能力。
本研究考察了结构性脆弱性如何影响人们对 IOAT 公民身份的构建和主张能力。研究结果表明,需要在 IOAT 项目内外进行变革,例如采用较低门槛的治疗模式、改善社会服务(如安全住房)和疼痛管理支持。