Richard A. and Susan F. Smith Center for Outcomes Research, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, Boston, Massachusetts.
Department of Medicine, Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts.
JAMA Cardiol. 2024 Aug 1;9(8):748-757. doi: 10.1001/jamacardio.2024.1321.
Climate change may increase the risk of adverse cardiovascular outcomes by causing direct physiologic changes, psychological distress, and disruption of health-related infrastructure. Yet, the association between numerous climate change-related environmental stressors and the incidence of adverse cardiovascular events has not been systematically reviewed.
To review the current evidence on the association between climate change-related environmental stressors and adverse cardiovascular outcomes.
PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, and Cochrane Library were searched to identify peer-reviewed publications from January 1, 1970, through November 15, 2023, that evaluated associations between environmental exposures and cardiovascular mortality, acute cardiovascular events, and related health care utilization. Studies that examined only nonwildfire-sourced particulate air pollution were excluded. Two investigators independently screened 20 798 articles and selected 2564 for full-text review. Study quality was assessed using the Navigation Guide framework. Findings were qualitatively synthesized as substantial differences in study design precluded quantitative meta-analysis.
Of 492 observational studies that met inclusion criteria, 182 examined extreme temperature, 210 ground-level ozone, 45 wildfire smoke, and 63 extreme weather events, such as hurricanes, dust storms, and droughts. These studies presented findings from 30 high-income countries, 17 middle-income countries, and 1 low-income country. The strength of evidence was rated as sufficient for extreme temperature; ground-level ozone; tropical storms, hurricanes, and cyclones; and dust storms. Evidence was limited for wildfire smoke and inadequate for drought and mudslides. Exposure to extreme temperature was associated with increased cardiovascular mortality and morbidity, but the magnitude varied with temperature and duration of exposure. Ground-level ozone amplified the risk associated with higher temperatures and vice versa. Extreme weather events, such as hurricanes, were associated with increased cardiovascular risk that persisted for many months after the initial event. Some studies noted a small increase in cardiovascular mortality, out-of-hospital cardiac arrests, and hospitalizations for ischemic heart disease after exposure to wildfire smoke, while others found no association. Older adults, racial and ethnic minoritized populations, and lower-wealth communities were disproportionately affected.
Several environmental stressors that are predicted to increase in frequency and intensity with climate change are associated with increased cardiovascular risk, but data on outcomes in low-income countries are lacking. Urgent action is needed to mitigate climate change-associated cardiovascular risk, particularly in vulnerable populations.
气候变化可能通过直接的生理变化、心理困扰和破坏与健康相关的基础设施,增加不良心血管结局的风险。然而,众多与气候变化相关的环境应激因素与不良心血管事件的发生之间的关联尚未得到系统审查。
审查与气候变化相关的环境应激因素与不良心血管结局之间关联的现有证据。
从 1970 年 1 月 1 日至 2023 年 11 月 15 日,通过检索 PubMed、Embase、Web of Science 和 Cochrane Library,以确定评估环境暴露与心血管死亡率、急性心血管事件和相关医疗保健利用之间关联的同行评审出版物。仅检查非野火来源的颗粒物空气污染的研究被排除在外。两名调查人员独立筛选了 20798 篇文章,并选择了 2564 篇进行全文审查。使用导航指南框架评估研究质量。由于研究设计存在显著差异,无法进行定量荟萃分析,因此对研究结果进行了定性综合。
符合纳入标准的 492 项观察性研究中,有 182 项研究了极端温度,210 项研究了地面臭氧,45 项研究了野火烟雾,63 项研究了极端天气事件,如飓风、沙尘暴和干旱。这些研究来自 30 个高收入国家、17 个中等收入国家和 1 个低收入国家。极端温度、地面臭氧、热带风暴、飓风和旋风以及沙尘暴的证据强度被评为充足;野火烟雾的证据有限;干旱和泥石流的证据不足。暴露于极端温度与心血管死亡率和发病率增加有关,但与暴露温度和持续时间有关。地面臭氧加剧了与较高温度相关的风险,反之亦然。飓风等极端天气事件与心血管风险增加有关,这种风险在初始事件发生后持续数月。一些研究指出,暴露于野火烟雾后,心血管死亡率、院外心脏骤停和缺血性心脏病住院率略有增加,而其他研究则没有发现关联。老年人、少数族裔和较贫困社区受到的影响不成比例。
几种预计随着气候变化而增加频率和强度的环境应激因素与心血管风险增加有关,但缺乏关于低收入国家结局的数据。迫切需要采取行动减轻与气候变化相关的心血管风险,特别是在脆弱人群中。