Essa-Hadad Jumanah, Jansen Danielle E M C, Vervoort Johanna P M, Edelstein Michael
Azrieli Faculty of Medicine, Bar Ilan University, Safed, Israel.
Department of General Practice and Elderly Care Medicine, University Medical Center Groningen, University of Groningen, Groningen, 9712 CP, The Netherlands.
Isr J Health Policy Res. 2024 Dec 5;13(1):71. doi: 10.1186/s13584-024-00660-6.
Over 1.9 million Arabs live in Israel and constitute 21% of the total population. Despite being a disadvantaged minority population with wide gaps in health indicators, Arabs have higher Human Papillomavirus (HPV) and Measles, Mumps, and Rubella (MMR) vaccination rates compared with the general Jewish population.
In-depth interviews with 21 health care providers, 16 Arab mothers, and 16 teenagers were conducted to collect information about health system enablers to HPV and MMR vaccination. All interviews were conducted in Arabic by an Arab researcher, audio-recorded, transcribed, and analysed using thematic analysis of the transcripts. Themes were mapped according to the WHO Health Systems Building Block Framework.
We identified several health system enablers. On the service delivery level, accessible and availability of vaccination services, delivery of vaccines through the school system and mother child clinics, and framing vaccinations as the norm were themes. Personable characteristics of the health workforce, the health care providers belonging to the same cultural group, and high levels of trust towards healthcare professionals were reported. Vaccination provided at no cost was also identified. On the leadership/governance level, the Arab community felt equal treatment and distribution of services, which was also an enabler reported. Despite high vaccine uptakes, parents and teenagers had limited knowledge regarding vaccination, particularly HPV.
This study highlights that a combination of good access and delivery to vaccination, delivered by a culturally competent, available, accessible respectful workforce can enable disadvantaged minorities to achieve high vaccine coverage, in particular in a cultural context where the population trusts and follows medical advice. Such evidence can serve as a basis for developing policies, interventions, and guidance to improve vaccine uptake among other underserved minority communities.
超过190万阿拉伯人生活在以色列,占总人口的21%。尽管作为弱势群体,在健康指标方面存在巨大差距,但与犹太总人口相比,阿拉伯人的人乳头瘤病毒(HPV)以及麻疹、腮腺炎和风疹(MMR)疫苗接种率更高。
对21名医护人员、16名阿拉伯母亲和16名青少年进行了深入访谈,以收集有关卫生系统促进HPV和MMR疫苗接种的信息。所有访谈均由一名阿拉伯研究人员用阿拉伯语进行,录音、转录,并对转录本进行主题分析。主题根据世界卫生组织卫生系统构建模块框架进行映射。
我们确定了几个卫生系统促进因素。在服务提供层面,疫苗接种服务的可及性和可得性、通过学校系统和母婴诊所提供疫苗以及将疫苗接种视为常态是主题。报告了卫生工作者的亲和力、属于同一文化群体的医护人员,以及对医疗专业人员的高度信任。还发现了免费提供疫苗接种的情况。在领导/治理层面,阿拉伯社区感受到了平等的待遇和服务分配,这也是报告中的一个促进因素。尽管疫苗接种率很高,但家长和青少年对疫苗接种的知识有限,尤其是HPV方面。
本研究强调,由具备文化能力、随时可用、可及且受人尊敬的工作人员提供良好的疫苗接种可及性和服务,能够使弱势群体实现高疫苗接种覆盖率,特别是在民众信任并听从医疗建议的文化背景下。这些证据可作为制定政策、干预措施和指南的基础,以提高其他服务不足的少数群体社区的疫苗接种率。