Yaqoob Eesha, Khan Shahzad Ali, Zaidi Dua Abbas, Chaurasia Bipin, Khan Fazal Ullah, Evangelou Kyriacos, Sahitia Nimirta, Javed Saad
Department of Public Health, Violence, Injury Prevention and Disability Unit, Health Services Academy, Ministry of National Health Services Regulations and Coordination, Government of Pakistan, Islamabad, Pakistan.
Department of Public Health, Violence, Injury Prevention and Disability Unit, Health Services Academy, Islamabad, Pakistan.
Emerg Med Int. 2025 Feb 17;2025:2780171. doi: 10.1155/emmi/2780171. eCollection 2025.
Trauma is a major cause of morbidity and mortality globally, with road traffic accidents projected to be the leading cause of death by 2030. In developing countries like Pakistan, trauma patients face significant challenges in receiving timely and effective care. This study aimed to evaluate trauma centers in tertiary care hospitals in the twin cities of Pakistan to highlight gaps and pitfalls in trauma patient management. A descriptive cross-sectional study was conducted using the World Health Organization's Hospital Emergency Unit Assessment Tool (HEAT) at five major public sector hospitals in Islamabad and Rawalpindi. Data collection involved collaboration between the Violence, Injury Prevention and Disability Unit and key informants, including Emergency Room in-charges and Heads of Departments. Information on trauma protocols and guidelines was gathered. All hospitals provided 24/7 emergency services with access to operating rooms and laboratories. However, significant disparities were found in equipment availability, particularly portable X-rays (40% availability) and RDT/HIV testing (20% availability). Protocol adherence varied, with 80% of hospitals having clinical management protocols but only 20% having specific protocols for conditions like asthma exacerbation and maternal hemorrhage. This study identifies infrastructural deficiencies and highlights systemic barriers that contribute to inadequate trauma care delivery, underscoring the need for targeted reforms. The study highlights significant gaps in trauma care management in Pakistani tertiary care hospitals, including shortages of personnel, infrastructure deficiencies, and lack of standardized protocols. These findings underscore the urgent need for systemic improvements in trauma care delivery. Recommendations include increased investment in medical infrastructure, addressing staffing and training deficiencies, and standardizing clinical management protocols to enhance trauma care outcomes and reduce morbidity and mortality rates in Pakistan. This research contributes novel insights into the specific barriers faced by trauma care systems in Pakistan, which have not been previously addressed in existing literature.
创伤是全球发病和死亡的主要原因,预计到2030年道路交通事故将成为主要死因。在巴基斯坦等发展中国家,创伤患者在获得及时有效的治疗方面面临重大挑战。本研究旨在评估巴基斯坦双城三级医院的创伤中心,以突出创伤患者管理中的差距和缺陷。使用世界卫生组织的医院急诊科评估工具(HEAT),在伊斯兰堡和拉瓦尔品第的五家主要公共部门医院进行了描述性横断面研究。数据收集涉及暴力、伤害预防和残疾股与关键信息提供者之间的合作,包括急诊室负责人和各部门负责人。收集了有关创伤协议和指南的信息。所有医院均提供全天候急诊服务,并可使用手术室和实验室。然而,在设备可用性方面发现了显著差异,特别是便携式X光机(可用性为40%)和快速诊断检测/艾滋病毒检测(可用性为20%)。协议遵守情况各不相同,80%的医院有临床管理协议,但只有20%的医院有针对哮喘加重和产妇出血等情况的具体协议。本研究确定了基础设施缺陷,并突出了导致创伤护理提供不足的系统性障碍,强调了有针对性改革的必要性。该研究突出了巴基斯坦三级医院创伤护理管理中的重大差距,包括人员短缺、基础设施缺陷和缺乏标准化协议。这些发现强调了迫切需要对创伤护理提供进行系统性改进。建议包括增加对医疗基础设施的投资,解决人员配备和培训不足的问题,以及规范临床管理协议,以提高巴基斯坦的创伤护理效果,降低发病率和死亡率。这项研究为巴基斯坦创伤护理系统面临的具体障碍提供了新的见解,这些障碍在现有文献中尚未得到解决。