Granger Emily, Todd Jonathan, Charman Susan Christine, Cromwell Elizabeth, Davies Gwyneth, Frost Freddy, Gifford Alex, Huang Bin, Hamblett Nicole Mayer, Naehrlich Lutz, Ostrenga Josh, Stanojevic Sanja, Szczesniak Rhonda, Keogh Ruth
Department of Medical Statistics, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, UK
Cystic Fibrosis Foundation, Bethesda, Maryland, USA.
BMJ Open. 2025 Mar 25;15(3):e091357. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2024-091357.
Target trial emulation is a framework for evaluating the effects of treatments using observational data. The trial emulation approach involves specifying key elements of a protocol for a target trial (a randomised controlled trial designed to address the question of interest) and then describing how best to emulate the trial using observational data. Recent years have seen an uptake of target trial emulation in several disease areas, although there are limited examples in cystic fibrosis (CF). This protocol describes a study which aims to assess the applicability of target trial emulation in CF. We aim to emulate an existing trial in CF and assess to what extent the results from the trial can be replicated using registry data.
The target trial is a published randomised controlled trial which found evidence for beneficial effects of azithromycin use on lung function in young adults with CF. Two emulated trials are planned: one using data from the UK CF Registry and one using data from the US CF Registry. The inclusion and exclusion criteria, treatment and outcome definitions, follow-up period, and estimand of interest are all designed to match the published trial as closely as possible. The analysis step of the trial emulations will use causal inference methods to control for confounding. Results obtained in the emulated trials using registry data will be compared with those from the target trial.
Ethical approval has been granted by the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine Ethics Committee (Ref: 29609). This study has also been approved by the UK CF Registry Research Committee and the North Star Review Board. The results of this study will be published in a peer-reviewed journal and presented at relevant scientific conferences.
目标试验模拟是一种利用观察性数据评估治疗效果的框架。试验模拟方法包括明确目标试验(旨在解决感兴趣问题的随机对照试验)方案的关键要素,然后描述如何利用观察性数据最佳地模拟该试验。近年来,目标试验模拟已在多个疾病领域得到应用,尽管在囊性纤维化(CF)方面的实例有限。本方案描述了一项旨在评估目标试验模拟在CF中适用性的研究。我们旨在模拟一项CF领域的现有试验,并评估使用登记数据能在多大程度上复制该试验的结果。
目标试验是一项已发表的随机对照试验,该试验发现阿奇霉素对CF青年成人肺功能有益的证据。计划进行两项模拟试验:一项使用英国CF登记处的数据,另一项使用美国CF登记处的数据。纳入和排除标准、治疗和结局定义、随访期以及感兴趣的估计量均设计为尽可能与已发表的试验相匹配。试验模拟的分析步骤将使用因果推断方法来控制混杂因素。将使用登记数据在模拟试验中获得的结果与目标试验的结果进行比较。
伦敦卫生与热带医学学院伦理委员会已批准伦理许可(参考号:29609)。本研究也已获得英国CF登记处研究委员会和北极星审查委员会的批准。本研究结果将发表在同行评审期刊上,并在相关科学会议上展示。