Dey Michelle, Volken Thomas, Altwicker-Hámori Szilvia, Von Rhein Michael, Seiler Michelle, Laasner Ursula, Wieber Frank, Dratva Julia
School of Health Science, ZHAW Zurich University of Applied Sciences, Winterthur, Switzerland.
School of Management and Law, ZHAW Zurich University of Applied Sciences, Winterthur, Switzerland.
Swiss Med Wkly. 2025 May 15;155:3899. doi: 10.57187/s.3899.
There is a scarcity of studies that examined the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on different primary paediatric health services beyond the first pandemic year and with longitudinal analytical approaches. Concerning Switzerland, studies are also lacking that assessed the impact of the pandemic on primary paediatric health services with objective and representative data. The current study addresses these research gaps.
Representative Swiss health insurance data (covering 96% of the population) of 0-18-year-olds, aggregated by month and by age groups 0-5, 6-10, 11-15 and 16-18 years were used for the analyses. The study period was from January 2018 to March 2022. Interrupted time-series models were applied to compare pandemic and pre-pandemic health care utilisation. The first lockdown served as the point of differentiation between these two periods. Regular visits, urgent visits, well-child visits and telephone consultations as well as routine vaccinations in the primary care setting were used as outcomes.
Among 0-5-year-olds, the average utilisation rates of regular, urgent and well-child visits were statistically significantly lower during the pandemic compared to the pre-pandemic period. This decrease in utilisation was primarily due to an initial marked drop after the lockdown, followed by a partial recovery during the pandemic phase. Additionally, the average vaccination rates for measles/mumps/rubella were statistically significantly lower during the pandemic for this age group, without indication of a catch-up over the pandemic phase. For 6-10-year-olds, a decreased average utilisation of regular and urgent visits was found without a statistically significant recovery over the pandemic period. No statistically significant changes were shown for older age groups regarding regular or urgent visits. However, telephone consultations showed statistically significantly higher average utilisation rates during the pandemic compared to the pre-pandemic phase across all age groups.
Delayed or missed well-child visits, which might persist even after a certain recovery, pose the risk of delayed detection of clinical/developmental abnormalities. Furthermore, missed vaccinations for measles/mumps/rubella increase the likelihood of infections and outbreaks, which can be particularly dangerous for the youngest children. Therefore, promoting catch-up well-child visits and vaccinations is essential. Higher utilisation of telephone consultations during the pandemic may have partially compensated the underutilisation of face-to-face consultations/visits in young children. In adolescents, in whom no changes in the utilisation of face-to-face consultations were observed, the increased use of telephone consultations may indicate an increase in health concerns within this age group.
除了疫情的第一年,很少有研究采用纵向分析方法来考察新冠疫情对不同的初级儿科健康服务的影响。关于瑞士,也缺乏利用客观且具有代表性的数据来评估疫情对初级儿科健康服务影响的研究。本研究填补了这些研究空白。
分析使用了瑞士具有代表性的健康保险数据(覆盖96%的人口),数据按月份汇总,并按0 - 5岁、6 - 10岁、11 - 15岁和16 - 18岁年龄组进行统计。研究时间段为2018年1月至2022年3月。采用中断时间序列模型来比较疫情期间和疫情前的医疗保健利用率。第一次封锁作为这两个时期的区分点。将初级保健机构中的定期就诊、紧急就诊、健康儿童就诊、电话咨询以及常规疫苗接种作为研究结果。
在0 - 5岁儿童中,与疫情前相比,疫情期间定期就诊、紧急就诊和健康儿童就诊的平均利用率在统计学上显著降低。利用率的下降主要是由于封锁后最初的显著下降,随后在疫情阶段出现部分恢复。此外,该年龄组在疫情期间麻疹/腮腺炎/风疹的平均疫苗接种率在统计学上显著降低,且在疫情阶段没有出现补种的迹象。对于6 - 10岁儿童,定期就诊和紧急就诊的平均利用率有所下降,在疫情期间没有统计学上的显著恢复。对于年龄较大的年龄组,在定期或紧急就诊方面没有显示出统计学上的显著变化。然而,与疫情前相比,所有年龄组在疫情期间电话咨询的平均利用率在统计学上显著更高。
健康儿童就诊延迟或错过,即使在一定程度的恢复后可能仍然存在,这会带来临床/发育异常延迟发现的风险。此外,麻疹/腮腺炎/风疹疫苗接种错过增加了感染和疫情爆发的可能性,这对最小的儿童可能特别危险。因此,促进补种健康儿童就诊和疫苗接种至关重要。疫情期间电话咨询利用率较高可能部分弥补了幼儿面对面咨询/就诊利用率不足的情况。在青少年中,虽然未观察到面对面咨询利用率的变化,但电话咨询使用增加可能表明该年龄组健康关注度增加。