Yue Zi-Qi, Jiang Lu, Li Zhi-Gang, Wang Wei, Wang Ya-Wei
State Key Laboratory of Environmental Chemistry and Ecotoxicology,Research Center for Eco-Environmental Sciences,Chinese Academy of Sciences,Beijing 100085,China.
School of Environment,Hangzhou Institute for Advanced Study,University of Chinese Academy of Sciences,Hangzhou 310024,China.
Se Pu. 2025 Jul;43(7):779-792. doi: 10.3724/SP.J.1123.2024.10022.
Statistical evidence indicates that individuals spend approximately 90% of their time indoors on a daily basis. A multitude of human activities, including incense burning, cooking, smoking, and the use of electrical appliances, can contribute to indoor air pollution. This phenomenon poses a significant risk of indoor exposure to human health risks. Incense burning, as one of the major indoor pollution sources, has been increasing in use in recent years due to its special effects in religious practices and regional lifestyles. Incense usually consists of herbs, wood powder, bamboo sticks, scented materials, and binder powders, and the specific chemical composition of each type of material is complex due to different uses and manufacturing processes; and the degree of complete combustion, thermal degradation and volatilization processes of different types of incense vary greatly, resulting in the release of gaseous and particulate organic compounds whose compositions are not yet clear. Studies have shown that the emission factors of particulate matter released from incense burning may be much higher than those produced during the combustion of charcoal, wood and cigarettes. The levels of organic pollutants emitted by incense burning, such as aromatic hydrocarbons, esters, ketones, benzenes, and phenols, are much higher than outdoor levels. Prolonged exposure to incense smoke has been shown to cause respiratory damage and potential genotoxicity. Therefore, accurate identification and measurement of the organic pollutants emitted from incense burning is particularly important to accurately assess their environmental and population health risks. Herein, this study established an analytical method based on ultrasonic extraction-gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) for the simultaneous determination of 67 organic compounds in gaseous and particulate emissions from incense burning. These compounds include 29 esters, seven benzene series, 14 phenols, and 17 polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs). Particulate and gaseous components released during indoor incense burning were collected using quartz filter membrane and self-made XAD-2 resin sampling tubes, respectively. Non-targeted analysis of incense components was performed using a GC-quadrupole-Orbitrap high-resolution mass spectrometry (GC-Q-Orbitrap-HRMS) to achieve preliminary identification of trace organic compounds in the incense-burning samples. Subsequently, targeted analysis was conducted using GC-MS in selected ion monitoring (SIM) mode, with quantification performed using the external standard method. Method validation results demonstrated good linearity for all 67 organic compounds within the range of 10 to 500 μg/L, with correlation coefficients ()≥0.999 0. The limits of detection (LODs) and quantification (LOQs) were ranged from 0.02 to 0.33 µg/m³ and 0.03 to 0.67 µg/m³, respectively. At low, medium, and high spiked levels, the recoveries for the 67 organic compounds in the gaseous phase ranged from 72.7% to 119.0%, with relative standard deviations (RSDs) of 0.9% to 4.1%; for the particulate phase, the recoveries for the 67 organic compounds ranged from 71.5% to 118.9%, with RSDs of 0.7% to 9.5%. The established method was applied to the determination of indoor incense-burning samples (incense sticks and electrically heated incense powder), and the influence of different incineration methods on the types and contents of products was analyzed. The results indicated that during the same burning duration (30 min), the total content of gaseous and particulate organic compounds released from ignited incense sticks was higher than that from electrically heated powdered incense. The particulate organic compounds produced by the ignited incense sticks are mainly phenolics and PAHs, followed by esters, and benzene series. The composition of particulate organic compounds from electrically heated powdered incense was similar to that of incense sticks. A large amount of benzene series were detected in the gaseous organic compounds released by burning incense sticks, and the content was much higher than that of the other three types of organic compounds. The gaseous organic compounds released by electrically heated incense powder are mainly benzene series and phenols, followed by PAHs and esters. Compared with the previously reported related monitoring methods, this method is simpler and more efficient, providing a more convenient technical means for the sensitive screening of gaseous and particulate organic compounds released by incense burning.
统计证据表明,个体每天大约90%的时间都在室内度过。众多人类活动,包括焚香、烹饪、吸烟以及使用电器等,都会导致室内空气污染。这种现象给人类健康带来了显著的室内暴露风险。焚香作为主要的室内污染源之一,近年来因其在宗教活动和地域生活方式中的特殊作用,使用量不断增加。香通常由草本植物、木粉、竹签、香料和粘结剂粉末组成,由于用途和制造工艺不同,每种材料的具体化学成分都很复杂;不同类型香的完全燃烧程度、热降解和挥发过程差异很大,导致气态和颗粒态有机化合物的释放,其成分尚不清楚。研究表明,焚香释放的颗粒物排放因子可能远高于木炭、木材和香烟燃烧时产生的排放因子。焚香释放的有机污染物,如芳烃、酯类、酮类、苯类和酚类的水平远高于室外水平。长期接触焚香烟雾已被证明会导致呼吸道损伤和潜在的遗传毒性。因此,准确识别和测量焚香释放的有机污染物对于准确评估其对环境和人群健康的风险尤为重要。在此,本研究建立了一种基于超声萃取-气相色谱-质谱联用(GC-MS)的分析方法,用于同时测定焚香气态和颗粒态排放物中的67种有机化合物。这些化合物包括29种酯类、7种苯系物、14种酚类和17种多环芳烃(PAHs)。室内焚香过程中释放的颗粒态和气态成分分别使用石英滤膜和自制的XAD-2树脂采样管进行采集。使用气相色谱-四极杆-轨道阱高分辨率质谱(GC-Q-Orbitrap-HRMS)对香成分进行非靶向分析,以初步鉴定焚香样品中的痕量有机化合物。随后,采用气相色谱-质谱联用仪在选择离子监测(SIM)模式下进行靶向分析,并采用外标法进行定量。方法验证结果表明,所有67种有机化合物在10至500 μg/L范围内具有良好的线性,相关系数()≥0.999 0。检测限(LODs)和定量限(LOQs)分别为0.02至0.33 µg/m³和0.03至0.67 µg/m³。在低、中、高加标水平下,气态相中67种有机化合物的回收率为72.7%至119.0%,相对标准偏差(RSDs)为0.9%至4.1%;颗粒相中67种有机化合物的回收率为71.5%至118.9%,RSDs为0.7%至9.5%。所建立的方法应用于室内焚香样品(香棒和电加热香粉)的测定,并分析了不同焚烧方式对产物类型和含量的影响。结果表明,在相同燃烧时间(30分钟)内,点燃香棒释放的气态和颗粒态有机化合物的总含量高于电加热香粉。点燃香棒产生的颗粒态有机化合物主要是酚类和多环芳烃,其次是酯类和苯系物。电加热香粉产生的颗粒态有机化合物组成与香棒相似。燃烧香棒释放的气态有机化合物中检测到大量苯系物,其含量远高于其他三种有机化合物。电加热香粉释放的气态有机化合物主要是苯系物和酚类,其次是多环芳烃和酯类。与先前报道的相关监测方法相比,该方法更简单、高效,为灵敏筛查焚香释放的气态和颗粒态有机化合物提供了更便捷的技术手段。