Jamil Emmama, Saleem Zikria, Godman Brian, Ullah Matti, Amir Afreenish, Haseeb Abdul, Meyer Johanna C, Qamar Muhammad Usman, Almarzoky Abuhussain Safa S
Department of Pharmacy Practice, Faculty of Pharmacy, Bahauddin Zakariya University, Multan, Pakistan.
Department of Pharmacy Practice, Faculty of Pharmacy, Hamdard University Islamabad Campus, Islamabad, Pakistan.
Front Pharmacol. 2025 Aug 7;16:1600787. doi: 10.3389/fphar.2025.1600787. eCollection 2025.
Antimicrobial resistance (AMR) has become a global burden, with inappropriate antibiotic prescribing being an important contributing factor. Antibiotic prescribing guidelines play an important role in improving the quality of antibiotic use, provided they are evidence-based and regularly updated. As a result, they help reduce AMR, which is a critical challenge in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). Consequently, the objective of this study was to evaluate local, national, and international antibiotic prescribing guidelines currently available-especially among LMICs-and previous challenges, in light of the recent publication of the WHO AWaRe book, which provides future direction.
Google Scholar and PubMed searches were complemented by searching official country websites to identify antibiotic prescribing guidelines, especially those concerning empiric treatment of bacterial infections, for this narrative review. Data were collected on the country of origin, income level, guideline title, year of publication, development methodology, issuing organization, target population, scope, and coverage. In addition, documentation on implementation strategies, compliance, monitoring of outcome measures, and any associated patient education or counseling efforts were reviewed to assess guideline utilization.
RESULTS/FINDINGS: A total of 181 guidelines were included, with the majority originating from high-income countries (109, 60.2%), followed by lower-middle-income (40, 22.1%), low-income (18, 9.9%), and upper-middle-income (14, 7.7%) countries. The GRADE methodology was used in only 20.4% of the sourced guidelines, predominantly in high-income countries. Patient education was often underemphasized, particularly in LMICs. The findings highlighted significant disparities in the development, adaptation, and implementation of guidelines across different WHO regions, confirming the previously noted lack of standardization and comprehensiveness in LMICs.
Significant disparities exist in the availability, structure, and methodological rigor of antibiotic prescribing guidelines across countries with different income levels. Advancing the development and implementation of standardized, context-specific guidelines aligned with the WHO AWaRe framework-and supported by equity-focused reforms-can significantly strengthen antimicrobial stewardship and help address the public health challenge of AMR.
抗菌药物耐药性(AMR)已成为一项全球负担,抗生素处方不当是一个重要促成因素。抗生素处方指南若以证据为基础并定期更新,就能在提高抗生素使用质量方面发挥重要作用。因此,它们有助于降低AMR,这在低收入和中等收入国家(LMICs)是一项严峻挑战。鉴于世界卫生组织(WHO)基本药物的获得、使用及合理用药(AWaRe)手册的最新出版提供了未来方向,本研究的目的是评估当前可得的地方、国家和国际抗生素处方指南,尤其是低收入和中等收入国家的指南,以及以往的挑战。
通过在谷歌学术和PubMed上检索,并辅以检索各国官方网站,以确定抗生素处方指南,尤其是关于细菌感染经验性治疗的指南,用于本叙述性综述。收集了有关原产国、收入水平、指南标题、出版年份、制定方法、发布机构、目标人群、范围和覆盖范围的数据。此外,还审查了关于实施策略、依从性、结果指标监测以及任何相关患者教育或咨询工作的文档,以评估指南的利用情况。
结果/发现:共纳入181项指南,其中大多数来自高收入国家(109项,60.2%),其次是中低收入国家(40项,22.1%)、低收入国家(18项,9.9%)和高收入国家(14项,7.7%)。仅20.4%的来源指南使用了推荐分级的评估、制定与评价(GRADE)方法,主要是在高收入国家。患者教育往往未得到充分重视,尤其是在低收入和中等收入国家。研究结果凸显了不同世卫组织区域在指南制定、调整和实施方面存在显著差异,证实了之前提到的低收入和中等收入国家缺乏标准化和全面性的情况。
不同收入水平国家在抗生素处方指南的可得性、结构和方法严谨性方面存在显著差异。推进与WHO AWaRe框架一致、针对具体情况且得到注重公平改革支持的标准化指南的制定和实施,可显著加强抗菌药物管理,并有助于应对AMR这一公共卫生挑战。