Levakin I A, Nikolaev K E
Parazitologiia. 2003 Sep-Oct;37(5):402-10.
A comparison of simple probability analytic model of infection rate depending on host's age with natural infection rate of mussels (Bivalvia: Mythilidae) with metacercariae Himasthla elongata (Trematoda: Echinostomidae) was carried out. Data on the natural rate of infection were accumulated during 3 years; 1152 individuals M. edulis were collected in two horizons within fucoid zone of the Kruglaya inlet and the Chupa inlet of the Kandalaksha bay (White Sea). A size of shell and number of H. elongata metacercariae were defined for each mussel using compressive dissection technique. The infection of mussels per year within our model is considers as independent evens: Pn = 1 - (1 - p)n, where n is the age of mussels, Pn is the theoretical part of infected n-year mussels, p is the probability of infection within one year. The probability of infection within year is assumed equal for every age of host. The estimate of probability of infection per year on the basis of sample of n-year's mussels was calculated as Pn = 1 - n square root of 1 - I(n), where n is the age of mussels, I(n) is the part of infected n-year mussels. The retransformed weighted average value of aresine-transformed p'n was used as p in our model (p = 0.3476). Statistically significant differences between empirical and theoretical (calculated from our models on the basis this value) infection rates were not found (P > > 0.05 chi 2-test). Moreover, statistical significant differences were absent (P > 0.05 Fisher exact test) in pairwise comparisons between empirical and theoretical infection rates for each age of mussels. The model does not take into consideration an effect of such factors as host's resistance, host's migration and increase of mortality in infected hosts. The absence of significant differences between the empirical and theoretical infection rates allows to suggest, that mentioned factors under the conditions of the Kruglaya inlet do not influence essentially onto infection of mussels with metacercariae H. elongata. This conclusions is in certain inconsistency with essential differences in such characteristic as an individual resistance of mussels to the infection with metacercariae H. elongata, detected in experiments in vitro (Gorbushin, Levakin, unpublished data). Analysis of intensity of the invasion of metacercariae H. elongata into mussels allows to suggest the existence of differential death rate of the hosts, which is exhibited in individuals over 7 years old. Studied example of mussels infected with metacercariae H. elongata under conditions of the Kruglaya inlet shows that the simple probabilistic model of the natural infection rate is usable for this kind of investigation. Our study also allows to conclude that in this case the infection rate of hosts is mainly determined by stochastic reasons. However, in some cases the probability of infection rate may not depend on the age and size of the host. The study of infection rate can not be used for analyses of individual differences of hosts in a resistance to parasites and an infection ability of the parasite.
对基于宿主年龄的感染率简单概率分析模型与贻贝(双壳纲:贻贝科)被长形希马斯吸虫(吸虫纲:棘口科)尾蚴自然感染率进行了比较。关于自然感染率的数据是在3年期间积累的;在坎达拉克沙湾(白海)克鲁格拉亚湾和丘帕湾的岩藻区两个层面收集了1152只食用贻贝个体。使用压缩解剖技术确定了每只贻贝的壳大小和长形希马斯吸虫尾蚴数量。在我们的模型中,贻贝每年的感染被视为独立事件:Pn = 1 - (1 - p)n,其中n是贻贝年龄,Pn是n岁感染贻贝的理论比例,p是一年内感染的概率。假定宿主各年龄每年的感染概率相等。基于n岁贻贝样本计算每年感染概率的估计值为Pn = 1 - n次根号下(1 - I(n)),其中n是贻贝年龄,I(n)是n岁感染贻贝的比例。在我们的模型中,反正弦变换后的p'n的重新转换加权平均值用作p(p = 0.3476)。未发现经验感染率与理论感染率(根据该值从我们的模型计算得出)之间存在统计学显著差异(P >> 0.05卡方检验)。此外,在对各年龄贻贝的经验感染率与理论感染率进行成对比较时,也不存在统计学显著差异(P > 0.05费舍尔精确检验)。该模型未考虑宿主抵抗力、宿主迁移以及感染宿主死亡率增加等因素的影响。经验感染率与理论感染率之间不存在显著差异,这表明在克鲁格拉亚湾的条件下,上述因素对贻贝被长形希马斯吸虫尾蚴感染基本上没有影响。这一结论与在体外实验中检测到的贻贝对长形希马斯吸虫尾蚴感染的个体抵抗力等特征存在本质差异有些不一致(戈尔布什金、列瓦金,未发表数据)。对长形希马斯吸虫尾蚴侵入贻贝强度的分析表明,宿主存在差异死亡率,这在7岁以上个体中表现出来。在克鲁格拉亚湾条件下研究的被长形希马斯吸虫尾蚴感染的贻贝实例表明,自然感染率的简单概率模型可用于此类调查。我们的研究还可以得出结论,在这种情况下,宿主的感染率主要由随机因素决定。然而,在某些情况下,感染率的概率可能不取决于宿主的年龄和大小。感染率的研究不能用于分析宿主对寄生虫抵抗力的个体差异以及寄生虫的感染能力。