Drukker Marjan, Feron Frans J M, van Os Jim
Dept. of Psychiatry and Neuropsychology South Limburg Mental Health Research and Teaching Network, EURON, Maastricht University, Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Soc Psychiatry Psychiatr Epidemiol. 2004 Jun;39(6):457-63. doi: 10.1007/s00127-004-0768-y.
Associations were examined between neighbourhood income inequality and neighbourhood socioeconomic deprivation on the one hand and (mental) health related quality of life (QoL) on the other, in Maastricht, the Netherlands.
Three different data sources were used: 1) neighbourhood socioeconomic indicators, 2) house prices per postal code area aggregated to an inequality measure at neighbourhood level, and 3) individual data measured in a family cohort study. Maastricht families with children aged approximately 11 years received questionnaires including the parents' QoL and family socioeconomic status (response rate: 60%). Multilevel analyses were conducted using neighbourhood level, family level, and individual level data.
Income inequality at neighbourhood level was not associated with QoL, whereas socioeconomic deprivation was associated with environment-related QoL.
The relative income hypothesis, according to which it is the contrast in deprivation rather than the absolute level of deprivation that influences health outcomes, does not hold at the neighbourhood level. Income inequality may only have an effect in larger areas containing sufficient socioeconomic contrast.
在荷兰马斯特里赫特,研究邻里收入不平等和邻里社会经济剥夺与(心理)健康相关生活质量(QoL)之间的关联。
使用了三种不同的数据源:1)邻里社会经济指标;2)按邮政编码区域汇总的房价,以此衡量邻里层面的不平等程度;3)在一项家庭队列研究中测量的个体数据。有大约11岁孩子的马斯特里赫特家庭收到了问卷,其中包括父母的生活质量和家庭社会经济状况(回复率:60%)。使用邻里层面、家庭层面和个体层面的数据进行了多层次分析。
邻里层面的收入不平等与生活质量无关,而社会经济剥夺与环境相关的生活质量有关。
相对收入假说认为,影响健康结果的是剥夺程度的差异而非剥夺的绝对水平,这一假说在邻里层面并不成立。收入不平等可能仅在具有足够社会经济差异的较大区域产生影响。