Abuaku B K, Koram K A, Binka F N
Noguchi Memorial Institute for Medical Research, University of Ghana, Legon, Ghana.
Med Princ Pract. 2005 Sep-Oct;14(5):332-7. doi: 10.1159/000086931.
The study was conducted to determine antimalarial prescribing practices among prescribers in 2 of the 6 sentinel sites established to document antimalarial drug efficacy in Ghana in order to provide some explanation underlying chloroquine treatment failures in the country.
The study was descriptive combining both qualitative and quantitative designs. The qualitative design involved in-depth interviews of general prescribers in the Wassa West and Kassena Nankana districts using an interview guide. The quantitative design involved a review of Outpatient Department prescriptions of 100 patients clinically diagnosed as having malaria within the year 2000 in each of the 7 selected health care facilities.
The overall number of drugs prescribed per patient encounter was 4.3 in the Wassa West district and 3.0 in the Kassena Nankana district. The number of drugs per patient encounter was 5.4 and 3.7 in private and government health care facilities, respectively. The commonly prescribed antimalarial drug in all the health care facilities visited was chloroquine. However, only 9.8% of prescriptions in private health care facilities contained correct doses of chloroquine compared to 54% in government health care facilities (p = 0.000). Prescriptions containing chloroquine injections were least likely to have correct doses of chloroquine.
The findings indicate that although chloroquine remained the first-line drug in the treatment of uncomplicated malaria in the two districts, the level of appropriateness of doses prescribed was generally low. Inappropriate doses of chloroquine prescribed were more prevalent in private than government health care facilities, and among prescriptions containing injections.
开展本研究以确定在加纳设立的6个用于记录抗疟药疗效的哨点中的2个哨点的处方医生的抗疟药处方习惯,以便对该国氯喹治疗失败的潜在原因作出一些解释。
本研究为描述性研究,结合了定性和定量设计。定性设计包括使用访谈提纲对瓦萨西区和卡塞纳-南卡纳区的普通处方医生进行深入访谈。定量设计包括对7家选定医疗机构中2000年临床诊断为疟疾的100例患者的门诊处方进行回顾。
在瓦萨西区,每次诊疗为患者开具的药物总数为4.3种,在卡塞纳-南卡纳区为3.0种。在私立和政府医疗机构中,每次诊疗为患者开具的药物数量分别为5.4种和3.7种。在所有受访医疗机构中,最常开具的抗疟药是氯喹。然而,私立医疗机构中只有9.8%的氯喹处方剂量正确,而政府医疗机构中这一比例为54%(p = 0.000)。含有氯喹注射剂的处方最不可能有正确剂量的氯喹。
研究结果表明,虽然氯喹在这两个地区仍然是治疗非复杂性疟疾的一线药物,但所开剂量的适宜性普遍较低。私立医疗机构中开具的氯喹剂量不当比政府医疗机构更普遍,且在含有注射剂的处方中更为常见。