Tapia Patrick C
University of Alabama School of Medicine, Medical Student Service, VH P-100, 1530 3rd Avenue S, Birmingham, AL 35294-0019, USA.
Med Hypotheses. 2006;66(4):832-43. doi: 10.1016/j.mehy.2005.09.009. Epub 2005 Oct 18.
The precise mechanistic sequence producing the beneficial effects on health and lifespan seen with interventions as diverse as caloric restriction, intermittent fasting, exercise, and consumption of dietary phytonutrients is still under active characterization, with large swaths of the research community kept in relative isolation from one another. Among the explanatory models capable of assisting in the identification of precipitating elements responsible for beneficial influences on physiology seen in these states, the hormesis perspective on biological systems under stress has yielded considerable insight into likely evolutionarily consistent organizing principles functioning in all four conditions. Recent experimental findings provide the tantalizing initial lodestones for an entirely new research front examining molecular substrates of stress resistance. In this novel body of research, a surprising new twist has emerged: Reactive oxygen species, derived from the mitochondrial electron transport system, may be necessary triggering elements for a sequence of events that result in benefits ranging from the transiently cytoprotective to organismal-level longevity. With the recent appreciation that reactive oxygen species and reactive nitrogen species function as signaling elements in a interconnected matrix of signal transduction, the entire basis of many widely accepted theories of aging that predominated in the past may need to be reconsidered to facilitate the formulation of an new perspective more correctly informed by the most contemporaneous experimental findings. This perspective, the mitohormesis theory, can be used in many disparate domains of inquiry to potentially explain previous findings, as well as point to new targets of research. The utility of this perspective for research on aging is significant, but beyond that this perspective emphasizes the pressing need to rigorously characterize the specific contribution of the stoichiometry of reactive oxygen species and reactive nitrogen species in the various compartments of the cell to cytoprotection and vitality. Previous findings regarding the influences of free radical chemistry on cellular physiology may have represented assessments examining the consequences of isolated elevation of signaling elements within a larger signal transductive apparatus, rather than definitive characterizations of the only modality of reactive oxygen species (and reactive nitrogen species) influence. In applying this perspective, it may be necessary for the research community, as well as the practicing clinician, to engender a more sanguine perspective on organelle level physiology, as it is now plausible that such entities have an evolutionarily orchestrated capacity to self-regulate that may be pathologically disturbed by overzealous use of antioxidants, particularly in the healthy.
热量限制、间歇性禁食、运动以及食用膳食植物营养素等多种干预措施对健康和寿命产生有益影响的确切机制序列仍在积极研究中,众多研究群体之间相对孤立。在能够协助识别这些状态下对生理产生有益影响的诱发因素的解释模型中,应激状态下生物系统的兴奋效应观点为这四种情况中可能存在的进化上一致的组织原则提供了相当多的见解。最近的实验结果为一个全新的研究前沿提供了诱人的初步指引,该前沿旨在研究抗应激的分子基础。在这一全新的研究领域中,出现了一个惊人的新转折:源自线粒体电子传递系统的活性氧可能是一系列事件的必要触发因素,这些事件带来的益处从短暂的细胞保护到机体层面的长寿。随着最近人们认识到活性氧和活性氮在相互关联的信号转导矩阵中作为信号元件发挥作用,过去许多占主导地位的被广泛接受的衰老理论的整个基础可能需要重新考虑,以便形成一个更符合最新实验结果的新观点。这种观点,即线粒体应激理论,可用于许多不同的研究领域,以潜在地解释先前的发现,并指出新的研究目标。这种观点对衰老研究的实用性是显著的,但除此之外,它强调迫切需要严格确定活性氧和活性氮的化学计量在细胞各个区室中对细胞保护和活力的具体贡献。先前关于自由基化学对细胞生理影响的研究结果可能代表了在更大的信号转导装置中对信号元件孤立升高后果的评估,而不是对活性氧(和活性氮)影响的唯一模式的确定性描述。在应用这一观点时,研究群体以及临床医生可能需要对细胞器水平的生理学形成更乐观的看法,因为现在很有可能这些实体具有进化上精心编排的自我调节能力,而过度热心地使用抗氧化剂可能会在病理上干扰这种能力,尤其是在健康人群中。