Maeck Lienhard, Haak Sebastian, Knoblauch Anita, Stoppe Gabriela
University Psychiatric Hospitals, Basel, Switzerland.
Int J Geriatr Psychiatry. 2008 Apr;23(4):415-21. doi: 10.1002/gps.1896.
By means of a representative follow-up survey, we investigated changes in family physicians' (FPs) attitudes towards cognition enhancers in early dementia during 1993 and 2001.
One hundred and twenty-two FPs (response rate 71.8%) in Lower Saxony, Germany, were randomly assigned to one of two written case samples presenting a patient with cognitive decline suggestive of early Alzheimer's disease (DAT; case A: female patient vs case B: male patient). Using a structured face-to-face interview, they were asked to suggest their potential drug treatment. The results were compared to corresponding data from our previous survey in 1993.
FPs' readiness to start antidementia drug treatment decreased from 70.4% in 1993 to 43.4% at follow-up, although underlying DAT was significantly more frequently suggested (11.0% vs 26.2%, p < 0.05). Substances with questionable efficacy such as Piracetame were prescribed less frequently in 2001 whereas evidence-based medication like cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEIs) failed to compensate for this drop. Compared to 1993, when 55.2% of FPs expected no therapeutic impact, at follow-up, 75.4% expected slowdown of disease progression, stabilisation or improvement of symptoms (p < 0.05).
Our results demonstrate a significant decrease of therapeutic nihilism in primary care within eight years. However, in patients with suspicion of DAT, this is not reflected accordingly in potential treatment.
通过一项具有代表性的随访调查,我们研究了1993年至2001年间家庭医生(FPs)对早期痴呆症认知增强剂态度的变化。
德国下萨克森州的122名家庭医生(回复率71.8%)被随机分配到两个书面病例样本组之一,这两个样本呈现出一名有认知能力下降迹象、疑似早期阿尔茨海默病(DAT)的患者(病例A:女性患者;病例B:男性患者)。通过结构化的面对面访谈,要求他们提出可能的药物治疗建议。将结果与我们1993年之前调查的相应数据进行比较。
尽管随访时疑似DAT的情况显著增多(11.0%对26.2%,p<0.05),但家庭医生开始使用抗痴呆药物治疗的意愿从1993年的70.4%降至随访时的43.4%。2001年,像吡拉西坦这种疗效存疑的药物处方频率降低,而像胆碱酯酶抑制剂(ChEIs)这种有循证依据的药物未能弥补这一下降。与1993年相比,当时55.2%的家庭医生预期无治疗效果,而在随访时,75.4%的家庭医生预期疾病进展会减缓、症状会稳定或改善(p<0.05)。
我们的结果表明,八年内在初级保健中治疗虚无主义显著减少。然而,在疑似DAT的患者中,这在潜在治疗中并未得到相应体现。