Read Andrew F, Lynch Penelope A, Thomas Matthew B
Centre for Infectious Disease Dynamics, Department of Biology, Pennsylvania State University, University Park, Pennsylvania, United States of America.
PLoS Biol. 2009 Apr 7;7(4):e1000058. doi: 10.1371/journal.pbio.1000058.
Insecticides are one of the cheapest, most effective, and best proven methods of controlling malaria, but mosquitoes can rapidly evolve resistance. Such evolution, first seen in the 1950s in areas of widespread DDT use, is a major challenge because attempts to comprehensively control and even eliminate malaria rely heavily on indoor house spraying and insecticide-treated bed nets. Current strategies for dealing with resistance evolution are expensive and open ended, and their sustainability has yet to be demonstrated. Here we show that if insecticides targeted old mosquitoes, and ideally old malaria-infected mosquitoes, they could provide effective malaria control while only weakly selecting for resistance. This alone would greatly enhance the useful life span of an insecticide. However,such weak selection for resistance can easily be overwhelmed if resistance is associated with fitness costs. In that case, late-life-acting insecticides would never be undermined by mosquito evolution.We discuss a number of practical ways to achieve this, including different use of existing chemical insecticides,biopesticides, and novel chemistry. Done right, a one-off investment in a single insecticide would solve the problem of mosquito resistance forever.
杀虫剂是控制疟疾最便宜、最有效且已得到充分验证的方法之一,但蚊子能够迅速进化出抗药性。这种进化最早在20世纪50年代广泛使用滴滴涕的地区被发现,它是一个重大挑战,因为全面控制甚至消除疟疾的努力严重依赖于室内房屋喷洒和经杀虫剂处理的蚊帐。当前应对抗药性进化的策略成本高昂且无休无止,其可持续性尚未得到证实。我们在此表明,如果杀虫剂针对年老蚊子,理想情况下是针对感染疟疾的年老蚊子,那么它们在有效控制疟疾的同时,只会对产生抗药性起到微弱的选择作用。仅此一点就能大大延长杀虫剂的使用寿命。然而,如果抗药性与适合度代价相关,那么这种对产生抗药性的微弱选择很容易被克服。在那种情况下,作用于蚊子生命后期的杀虫剂永远不会因蚊子的进化而失效。我们讨论了实现这一目标的一些切实可行的方法,包括对现有化学杀虫剂、生物杀虫剂和新型化学物质的不同使用方式。如果方法得当,对单一杀虫剂进行一次性投资就能永远解决蚊子抗药性问题。