Tomioka Haruaki
Department of Microbiology and Immunology Shimane University School of Medicine Izumo, Shimane 693-8501 Japan.
Curr Pharm Des. 2014;20(27):4305-6. doi: 10.2174/1381612819666131118203915.
Worldwide, tuberculosis (TB) remains the most frequent and important infectious disease causing morbidity and death. However, the development of new drugs for the treatment and prophylaxis of TB, particularly those truly active against dormant and persistent types of tubercle bacilli, has been slow, although some promising drugs, such as diarylquinoline TMC207, nitroimidazopyran PA-824, nitroimidazo-oxazole Delamanid (OPC-67683), oxazolidinone PNU-100480, ethylene diamine SQ-109, and pyrrole derivative LL3858, are currently under phase 1 to 3 clinical trials. Therefore, novel types of antituberculous drug, which act on unique drug targets in Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) pathogens, particularly drug targets related to the establishment of mycobacterial dormancy in the host's macrophages, are urgently needed. In this context, it should be noted that current anti-TB drugs mostly target the metabolic reactions and proteins which are essential for the growth of MTB in extracellular milieus. It may also be promising to develop another type of drug that exerts an inhibitory action against bacterial virulence factors which cross-talk and interfere with signaling pathways of MTB-infected immunocompetent host cells, such as lymphocytes, macrophages, and NK cells, thereby changing the intracellular milieus that are favorable to intramacrophage survival and the growth of infected bacilli. This special issue contains ten review articles, dealing with recent approaches to identify and establish novel drug targets in MTB for the development of new and unique antitubercular drugs, including those related to mycobacterial dormancy and crosstalk with cellular signaling pathways. In addition, this special issue contains some review papers with special reference to the drug design based on quantitative structure-activity relationship (QSAR) analysis, especially three-dimensional (3D)-QSAR. New, critical information on the entire genome of MTB and mycobacterial virulence genes is promoting the elucidation of the molecular structures of drug targets in MTB, and are consequently markedly useful for the design of new, promising antituberculous drugs using QSAR techniques. In this issue, we review the following areas. Firstly, Dr. Li M. Fu reviews the perspective that combines machine learning and genomics for drug discovery in tuberculosis, in relation to the problem that the exhaustive search for useful drug targets over the entire MTB genome would not be as productive as expected in practice [1]. Secondly, the review article by Drs. R. S. Chauhan. S. K. Chanumolu, C. Rout, and R. Shrivastava focuses on analysis of the current state of MTB genomic resources, host-pathogen interaction studies in the context of mycobacterial persistence, and drug target discovery based on the utilization of computational tools and metabolic network analyses [2]. Thirdly, Drs. Daria Bottai, Agnese Serafini, Alessandro Cascioferro, Roland Brosch, and Riccardo Manganelli review the current knowledge on MTB T7SS/ESX secretion systems and their impact on MTB physiology and virulence, and the possible approaches to develop T7SS/ESX inhibitors [3]. Fourthly, Drs. E. Jeffrey North, Mary Jackson, and Richard E. Lee review and analyze new and emerging inhibitors of the mycolic acid biosynthetic pathway, including mycobacterial enzymes for fatty acid synthesis, mycolic acid-modifying enzymes, fatty acid-activating and -condensing enzymes, transporters, and transferases, that have been discovered in the post-genomic era of tuberculosis drug discovery [4]. Fifthly, Drs. Katarina Mikusova, Vadim Makarov, and Joao Neres review the mycobacterial enzyme DprE1, which catalyzes a unique epimerization reaction in the biosynthesis of decaprenylphosphoryl arabinose, a single donor of the arabinosyl residue for the build-up of arabinans, one of the mycobacterial cell wall components, as an important drug target especially for the development of benzothiazinones [5]. Sixthly, I review the present status of global research on novel drug targets related to the Toll-like receptor in the MTB pathogen, with special reference to mycobacterial virulence factors that cross-talk and interfere with signaling pathways of host macrophages [6]. The following four review articles deal with drug design of novel anti-TB agents employing QSAR techniques. Firstly, Drs. Nidhi and Mohammad Imran Siddiqi review 2D and 3D QSAR approaches and the recent trends of these methods integrated with virtual screening using the 3D pharmacophore and molecular docking approaches for the identification and design of novel antituberculous agents, by presenting a comprehensive overview of QSAR studies reported for newer antituberculous agents [7]. Secondly, Drs. Filomena Martins, Cristina Ventura, Susana Santos, and Miguel Viveiros review the current status of different QSAR-based strategies for the design of novel anti-TB drugs based upon the most active anti-TB agent, isoniazid, from the viewpoint of the development of promising derivatives that are active against isoniazid- resistant strains with katG mutations [8]. Thirdly, Drs. Sanchaita Rajkhowa and Ramesh C. Deka review current studies concerning 2D and 3D QSAR models that contain density-functional theory (DFT)-based descriptors as their parameters [9]. Notably, DFT-based descriptors such as atomic charges, molecular orbital energies, frontier orbital densities, and atom-atom polarizabilities are very useful in predicting the reactivity of atoms in molecules. Fourthly, Drs. Renata V. Bueno, Rodolpho C. Braga, Natanael D. Segretti, Elizabeth I. Ferreira, Gustavo H. G. Trossini, and Carolina H. Andrade review the current progress and applications of QSAR analysis for the discovery of innovative tuberculostatic agents as inhibitors of ribonucleotide reductase, DNA gyrase, ATP synthase, and thymidylate kinase enzymes, highlighting present challenges and new opportunities in TB drug design [10]. The aim of this issue is to address the future prospects for the development of new antituberculous drugs. There are a number of difficulties in computational drug-design for the development of new drug formulations with potential antimycobacterial effects, especially therapeutic and prophylactic efficacy against infection due to dormant-type MTB pathogens. In addition, it should be emphasized that the most urgent goal of TB chemotherapy is develop highly active, low-cost drugs which can be used not only in industrialized but also in developing countries, because most global TB incidence occurs in the latter. I am sincerely grateful to the individuals who contributed to this work. All authors are experts in their fields and they made earnest efforts to perform these in-depth reviews. I thank them all.
在全球范围内,结核病(TB)仍然是导致发病和死亡的最常见且最重要的传染病。然而,用于治疗和预防结核病的新药研发进展缓慢,尤其是那些对休眠和持续存在的结核杆菌真正有效的药物,尽管一些有前景的药物,如二芳基喹啉TMC207、硝基咪唑并吡喃PA - 824、硝基咪唑并恶唑地拉曼尼德(OPC - 67683)、恶唑烷酮PNU - 100480、乙二胺SQ - 109以及吡咯衍生物LL3858,目前正处于1至3期临床试验阶段。因此,迫切需要新型抗结核药物,这类药物作用于结核分枝杆菌(MTB)病原体中独特的药物靶点,特别是与结核杆菌在宿主巨噬细胞中建立休眠状态相关的药物靶点。在此背景下,应当注意到目前的抗结核药物大多靶向MTB在细胞外环境中生长所必需的代谢反应和蛋白质。开发另一种药物也可能具有前景,这种药物能够对细菌毒力因子发挥抑制作用,这些毒力因子会相互作用并干扰MTB感染的免疫活性宿主细胞(如淋巴细胞、巨噬细胞和NK细胞)的信号通路,从而改变有利于巨噬细胞内存活和感染杆菌生长的细胞内环境。本期特刊包含十篇综述文章,涉及近期在MTB中鉴定和建立新型药物靶点以开发新型独特抗结核药物的方法,包括与结核杆菌休眠以及与细胞信号通路相互作用相关的靶点。此外,本期特刊还包含一些特别提及基于定量构效关系(QSAR)分析,尤其是三维(3D) - QSAR的药物设计的综述论文。关于MTB全基因组和结核杆菌毒力基因的新的关键信息正在推动对MTB中药物靶点分子结构的阐明,因此对于使用QSAR技术设计新的、有前景的抗结核药物非常有用。在本期中,我们综述以下领域。首先,李M. 傅博士综述了将机器学习和基因组学相结合用于结核病药物发现的观点,涉及在整个MTB基因组中详尽搜索有用药物靶点在实际中并非如预期那样富有成效的问题[1]。其次,R. S. 乔汉博士、S. K. 查努莫卢博士、C. 劳特博士和R. 什里瓦斯塔瓦博士的综述文章重点分析了MTB基因组资源的现状、在结核杆菌持续存在背景下的宿主 - 病原体相互作用研究以及基于计算工具利用和代谢网络分析的药物靶点发现[2]。第三,达里亚·博塔伊博士、阿涅塞·塞拉菲尼博士、亚历山德罗·卡斯乔费罗博士、罗兰·布罗施博士和里卡尔多·曼加内利博士综述了关于MTB T7SS/ESX分泌系统的当前知识及其对MTB生理学和毒力的影响,以及开发T7SS/ESX抑制剂的可能方法[3]。第四,E. 杰弗里·诺思博士、玛丽·杰克逊博士和理查德·E. 李博士综述并分析了分枝菌酸生物合成途径的新型及新兴抑制剂,包括在结核病药物发现的后基因组时代发现的用于脂肪酸合成的结核杆菌酶、分枝菌酸修饰酶、脂肪酸活化和缩合酶、转运蛋白以及转移酶[4]。第五,卡特琳娜·米库索娃博士、瓦迪姆·马卡罗夫博士和若昂·内雷斯博士综述了结核杆菌酶DprE1,它在癸酰磷酸阿拉伯糖的生物合成中催化一种独特的差向异构化反应,癸酰磷酸阿拉伯糖是用于构建阿拉伯聚糖(结核杆菌细胞壁成分之一)的阿拉伯糖基残基的单一供体,是一个重要的药物靶点,尤其对于苯并噻嗪酮类药物的开发[5]。第六,我综述了关于MTB病原体中与Toll样受体相关的新型药物靶点的全球研究现状,特别提及了与宿主巨噬细胞信号通路相互作用并干扰其信号通路的结核杆菌毒力因子[6]。接下来的四篇综述文章涉及采用QSAR技术的新型抗结核药物的药物设计。首先,尼迪博士和穆罕默德·伊姆兰·西迪基博士综述了二维和三维QSAR方法以及这些方法与使用三维药效团和分子对接方法进行虚拟筛选相结合的近期趋势,用于鉴定和设计新型抗结核药物,通过全面概述针对新型抗结核药物报道的QSAR研究[7]。其次,菲洛梅娜·马丁斯博士、克里斯蒂娜·文图拉博士、苏珊娜·桑托斯博士和米格尔·维韦罗斯博士从开发对具有katG突变的耐异烟肼菌株有效的有前景衍生物这一角度,综述了基于不同QSAR策略设计新型抗结核药物的现状,这些策略以最有效的抗结核药物异烟肼为基础[8]。第三,桑查伊塔·拉杰科瓦博士和拉梅什·C. 德卡博士综述了当前关于二维和三维QSAR模型的研究,这些模型包含基于密度泛函理论(DFT)的描述符作为其参数[9]。值得注意的是,基于DFT的描述符,如原子电荷、分子轨道能量、前沿轨道密度和原子 - 原子极化率,在预测分子中原子的反应性方面非常有用。第四,雷纳塔·V. 布埃诺博士、罗道夫·C. 布拉加博士、纳塔纳埃尔·D. 塞格雷蒂博士、伊丽莎白·I. 费雷拉博士、古斯塔沃·H. G. 特罗西尼博士和卡罗琳娜·H. 安德拉德博士综述了QSAR分析在发现作为核糖核苷酸还原酶、DNA回旋酶、ATP合酶和胸苷酸激酶酶抑制剂的数据创新抗结核药物方面的当前进展和应用,强调了结核病药物设计中的当前挑战和新机遇[10]。本期特刊的目的是探讨开发新型抗结核药物的未来前景。在开发具有潜在抗分枝杆菌作用,特别是对休眠型MTB病原体感染具有治疗和预防功效的新药物制剂的计算药物设计方面存在许多困难。此外,应当强调的是,结核病化疗最紧迫的目标是开发高活性、低成本的药物,这些药物不仅可在工业化国家使用,也可在发展中国家使用,因为全球大多数结核病发病发生在发展中国家。我衷心感谢为这项工作做出贡献的各位人士。所有作者都是各自领域的专家,他们认真努力地进行了这些深入的综述。我在此感谢他们所有人。