Sabbath Erika L, Glymour M Maria, Descatha Alexis, Leclerc Annette, Zins Marie, Goldberg Marcel, Berkman Lisa F
Harvard Center for Population and Development Studies, 9 Bow Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA.
Department of Society, Human Development, and Health, Harvard School of Public Health, 677 Huntington Avenue, 6th Floor, Boston, MA 02115, USA.
Adv Life Course Res. 2013 Dec;18(4):235-43. doi: 10.1016/j.alcr.2013.07.002. Epub 2013 Jul 13.
Biomechanical and psychosocial occupational exposures are seldom considered simultaneously and over extended follow-up in occupational epidemiologic studies, although there is some evidence that combined exposures have interactive effects on workers' health during working life. Given high prevalence of functional disability among retirees, research on earlier-life determinants of subsequent functional outcomes can help shape workplace policies and practices. This study investigates whether health effects of combined occupational exposures during working life are observed after individuals retire and are no longer exposed.
Analyses were conducted among retirees in the French GAZEL occupational cohort (n=9168). Cumulative exposure during working life to eight biomechanical strains and to one or more reports of psychosocial job strain (high-demand, low-control work) were assessed as predictors of three outcomes: difficulty with physical functioning, role limitations due to physical difficulties, and bodily pain. Individuals were classified by joint exposure to both biomechanical and psychosocial constraints. We modeled risk ratios (RR) between exposure to biomechanical and psychosocial factors at work (separately and in combination) and disability after retirement, and we calculated the relative excess risk due to interaction (RERI) to test whether combined effects departed from additivity.
Both psychosocial and biomechanical exposures during working life were independent predictors of the three functional health outcomes. Compared with individuals who had neither biomechanical nor psychosocial exposures, in fully adjusted log-binomial models of the combined effects of biomechanical and psychosocial exposure, among those with low biomechanical exposures, the RR for physical functioning difficulties associated with psychosocial exposures was 1.18 (95% CI 1.01, 1.37). Among those with the highest levels of biomechanical exposures, RR was 1.42 (95% CI 1.21, 1.65) among those with low psychosocial exposures and 1.91 (95% CI 1.61, 2.26) among those with high psychosocial exposures. The two exposure types were modestly super-additive, with an RERI of 0.32 (95% CI 0.00, 0.62) between those with the highest and lowest levels of biomechanical exposures; if the effects were strictly additive, we would have expected an RERI of 0. For the other two outcomes results were similar, although there was no significant departure from additivity. Some effects varied in magnitude by gender.
Across the sample, combined biomechanical and psychosocial occupational exposures during working life appear to have additive or perhaps interactive effects on functional health in retirement. However, the relationship is less straightforward among women. Improving overall working conditions may lessen future disability among retirees.
在职业流行病学研究中,生物力学和心理社会职业暴露很少在长期随访中同时被考虑,尽管有证据表明联合暴露在工作期间对工人健康有交互作用。鉴于退休人员中功能残疾的高患病率,对后续功能结局的早年决定因素进行研究有助于制定工作场所政策和实践。本研究调查了工作期间职业暴露联合作用对健康的影响在个体退休且不再暴露后是否依然存在。
对法国GAZEL职业队列中的退休人员(n = 9168)进行分析。工作期间累积暴露于八种生物力学应变以及一份或多份心理社会工作压力报告(高要求、低控制工作)被评估为三种结局的预测因素:身体功能困难、因身体困难导致的角色限制以及身体疼痛。个体根据生物力学和心理社会限制的联合暴露进行分类。我们对工作时生物力学和心理社会因素暴露(分别及联合)与退休后残疾之间的风险比(RR)进行建模,并计算交互作用导致的相对超额风险(RERI),以检验联合效应是否偏离相加性。
工作期间的心理社会和生物力学暴露都是三种功能健康结局的独立预测因素。与既无生物力学暴露也无心理社会暴露的个体相比,在生物力学和心理社会暴露联合效应的完全调整对数二项模型中,在生物力学暴露水平低的人群中,与心理社会暴露相关的身体功能困难的RR为1.18(95%CI 1.01,1.37)。在生物力学暴露水平最高的人群中,心理社会暴露水平低的人群RR为1.42(95%CI 1.21,1.65),心理社会暴露水平高的人群RR为1.91(95%CI 1.61,2.26)。这两种暴露类型有适度的超相加性,在生物力学暴露水平最高和最低的人群之间,RERI为0.32(95%CI 0.00,0.62);如果效应严格相加,我们预期RERI为0。对于其他两种结局,结果相似,尽管没有明显偏离相加性。一些效应在性别上大小有所不同。
在整个样本中,工作期间生物力学和心理社会职业暴露联合似乎对退休后的功能健康有相加或可能的交互作用。然而,女性中的这种关系不那么直接。改善整体工作条件可能会减少退休人员未来的残疾情况。