Sulenes Kari, Freitas Jillian, Justice Lauren, Colgan Dana Dharmakaya, Shean Margaret, Brems Christiane
School of Professional Psychology, Pacific University , Hillsboro, OR.
J Altern Complement Med. 2015 Jan;21(1):53-9. doi: 10.1089/acm.2014.0217. Epub 2014 Sep 30.
Nearly 38% of U.S. adults use complementary and alternative medicine approaches to manage physical conditions (e.g., chronic pain, arthritis, cancer, heart disease, and high blood pressure) and psychological or emotional health concerns (e.g., post-traumatic stress disorder, anxiety, and depression). Research evidence has accumulated for yoga as an effective treatment approach for these conditions. Further, yoga has increased in popularity among healthcare providers and the general population. Given these trends, this study explored perceptions about yoga as a viable complementary treatment to which health professions students would refer patients.
More than 1500 students enrolled in health professions programs at a Pacific Northwest school were enrolled; data were obtained from 478 respondents.
The study assessed willingness to refer patients to yoga as a complementary and alternative medicine for 27 symptoms (identified in the literature as having evidence for yoga's utility), which were subsequently grouped into skeletal, physical, and psychological on the basis of factor analysis. Responses were assessed using a mixed-model analysis of variance with health profession and yoga practitioner as between-subjects variables and symptoms as a within-subjects factor.
In descending order of likelihood to refer patients to yoga were students in occupational therapy, physician assistant program, psychology, physical therapy, pharmacy, dental hygiene, speech and audiology, and optometry. All groups perceived yoga's greatest utility for skeletal symptoms, followed by psychological and physical symptoms. Findings also revealed a significant positive relationship between level of personal yoga practice and willingness to refer patients to yoga.
Although students expressed some openness to referring patients to yoga, ratings of appropriateness were not accurately aligned with extant evidence base. Personal experience seemed to be a salient factor for accepting yoga as a referral target. These findings suggest the importance of developing strategies to make health professionals more aware of the merits of yoga, regardless of whether they themselves are yoga practitioners.
近38%的美国成年人采用补充和替代医学方法来管理身体状况(如慢性疼痛、关节炎、癌症、心脏病和高血压)以及心理或情绪健康问题(如创伤后应激障碍、焦虑和抑郁)。已有研究证据表明瑜伽是治疗这些疾病的有效方法。此外,瑜伽在医疗服务提供者和普通人群中越来越受欢迎。鉴于这些趋势,本研究探讨了健康专业学生将瑜伽视为一种可行的补充治疗方法并推荐给患者的看法。
太平洋西北地区一所学校的1500多名健康专业项目的学生参与了研究;数据来自478名受访者。
该研究评估了将患者转介至瑜伽作为补充和替代医学治疗27种症状(文献中已证实瑜伽对这些症状有用)的意愿,随后基于因子分析将这些症状分为骨骼、身体和心理三类。使用混合模型方差分析评估回答,将健康专业和瑜伽从业者作为组间变量,症状作为组内因素。
按将患者转介至瑜伽的可能性从高到低排序,职业治疗、医师助理项目、心理学、物理治疗、药学、口腔卫生、言语和听力学以及验光专业的学生依次排列。所有组都认为瑜伽对骨骼症状的效用最大,其次是心理和身体症状。研究结果还显示,个人瑜伽练习水平与将患者转介至瑜伽的意愿之间存在显著的正相关关系。
尽管学生们对将患者转介至瑜伽表现出一定的开放性,但合适性评分与现有证据基础并不准确一致。个人经验似乎是将瑜伽作为转介目标的一个显著因素。这些发现表明,制定策略使健康专业人员更多地了解瑜伽的优点非常重要,无论他们自己是否是瑜伽从业者。