Huang Hsien-Liang, Cheng Shao-Yi, Yao Chien-An, Hu Wen-Yu, Chen Ching-Yu, Chiu Tai-Yuan
From the Department of Family Medicine (HLH), Cardinal Tien Hospital, and Fu-Jen Catholic University, New Taipei City; Department of Family Medicine (SYC, CAY, CYC, TYC); and School of Nursing (WYH), College of Medicine and Hospital, National Taiwan University, Taipei, Taiwan.
Medicine (Baltimore). 2015 Apr;94(16):e657. doi: 10.1097/MD.0000000000000657.
Providing patient-centered care from preventive medicine to end-of-life care in order to improve care quality and reduce medical cost is important for accountable care. Physicians in the accountable care organizations (ACOs) are suitable for participating in supportive end-of-life care especially when facing issues in truth telling and treatment strategy. This study aimed to investigate patients' attitudes toward truth telling and treatment preferences in end-of-life care and compare patients' attitudes with their ACOs physicians' perceptions.This nationwide study applied snowball sampling to survey physicians in physician-led ACOs and their contracted patients by questionnaire from August 2010 to July 2011 in Taiwan. The main outcome measures were beliefs about palliative care, attitudes toward truth telling, and treatment preferences.The data of 314 patients (effective response rate = 88.7%) and 177 physicians (88.5%) were analyzed. Regarding truth telling about disease prognosis, 94.3% of patients preferred to be fully informed, whereas only 80% of their physicians had that perception (P < 0.001). Significant differences were also found in attitudes toward truth telling even when encountering terminal disease status (98.1% vs 85.3%). Regarding treatment preferences in terminal illness, nearly 90% of patients preferred supportive care, but only 15.8% of physicians reported that their patients had this preference (P < 0.001).Significant discrepancies exist between patients' preferences and physicians' perceptions toward truth telling and treatment strategies in end-of-life care. It is important to enhance physician-patient communication about end-of-life care preferences in order to achieve the goal of ACOs. Continuing education on communication about end-of-life care during physicians' professional development would be helpful in the reform strategies of establishing accountable care around the world.
从预防医学到临终关怀提供以患者为中心的护理,以提高护理质量并降低医疗成本,这对责任医疗至关重要。责任医疗组织(ACO)中的医生适合参与支持性临终关怀,尤其是在面对告知真相和治疗策略方面的问题时。本研究旨在调查患者对临终关怀中告知真相的态度和治疗偏好,并将患者的态度与其ACO医生的认知进行比较。这项全国性研究于2010年8月至2011年7月在台湾采用雪球抽样法,通过问卷调查对由医生主导的ACO中的医生及其签约患者进行调查。主要结局指标是对姑息治疗的信念、对告知真相的态度和治疗偏好。对314名患者(有效回复率=88.7%)和177名医生(88.5%)的数据进行了分析。关于疾病预后的告知,94.3%的患者希望得到充分告知,而他们的医生中只有80%有这种认知(P<0.001)。即使在面对终末期疾病状态时,在对告知真相的态度上也发现了显著差异(98.1%对85.3%)。关于晚期疾病的治疗偏好,近90%的患者更喜欢支持性护理,但只有15.8%的医生报告说他们的患者有这种偏好(P<0.001)。在临终关怀中,患者的偏好与医生对告知真相和治疗策略的认知之间存在显著差异。加强医患之间关于临终关怀偏好的沟通对于实现ACO的目标很重要。在医生的专业发展过程中开展关于临终关怀沟通的继续教育,将有助于全球范围内建立责任医疗的改革策略。