Adams Ted D, Mehta Tapan S, Davidson Lance E, Hunt Steven C
Division of Cardiovascular Genetics, University of Utah and Intermountain LiVe Well Center, 389 South 900 East, SLC, Salt Lake City, UT, 84102, USA.
Department of Physical Therapy, Nutrition Obesity Research Center, University of Alabama at Birmingham, School of Health Professions Building 370, 1705 University Blvd, Birmingham, AL, 35294, USA.
Curr Atheroscler Rep. 2015 Dec;17(12):74. doi: 10.1007/s11883-015-0551-4.
The question of whether or not nonsurgical intentional or voluntary weight loss results in reduced mortality has been equivocal, with long-term mortality following weight loss being reported as increased, decreased, and not changed. In part, inconsistent results have been attributed to the uncertainty of whether the intentionality of weight loss is accurately reported in large population studies and also that achieving significant and sustained voluntary weight loss in large intervention trials is extremely difficult. Bariatric surgery has generally been free of these conflicts. Patients voluntarily undergo surgery and the resulting weight is typically significant and sustained. These elements, combined with possible non-weight loss-related mechanisms, have resulted in improved comorbidities, which likely contribute to a reduction in long-term mortality. This paper reviews the association between bariatric surgery and long-term mortality. From these studies, the general consensus is that bariatric surgical patients have: 1) significantly reduced long-term all-cause mortality when compared to severely obese non-bariatric surgical control groups; 2) greater mortality when compared to the general population, with the exception of one study; 3) reduced cardiovascular-, stroke-, and cancer-caused mortality when compared to severely obese non-operated controls; and 4) increased risk for externally caused death such as suicide.
非手术性的有意或自愿减重是否会降低死亡率这一问题一直存在争议,有报告称减重后的长期死亡率有所增加、降低或未改变。部分原因在于,在大型人群研究中,减重的意图是否被准确报告存在不确定性,而且在大型干预试验中实现显著且持续的自愿减重极为困难。减肥手术通常不存在这些矛盾之处。患者自愿接受手术,术后体重减轻通常显著且持久。这些因素,再加上可能与体重减轻无关的机制,已导致合并症得到改善,这可能有助于降低长期死亡率。本文综述了减肥手术与长期死亡率之间的关联。从这些研究中得出的普遍共识是,接受减肥手术的患者:1)与严重肥胖的非减肥手术对照组相比,长期全因死亡率显著降低;2)与一般人群相比,除一项研究外,死亡率更高;3)与严重肥胖的未手术对照组相比,心血管疾病、中风和癌症导致的死亡率降低;4)外部原因导致的死亡风险增加,如自杀。