Sönnichsen Andreas, Trampisch Ulrike S, Rieckert Anja, Piccoliori Giuliano, Vögele Anna, Flamm Maria, Johansson Tim, Esmail Aneez, Reeves David, Löffler Christin, Höck Jennifer, Klaassen-Mielke Renate, Trampisch Hans Joachim, Kunnamo Ilkka
Institute of General Practice and Family Medicine, Witten/Herdecke University, Alfred-Herrhausen-Str. 50, 58448, Witten, Germany.
South Tyrolian Academy of General Practice, Bolzano, Italy.
Trials. 2016 Jan 29;17:57. doi: 10.1186/s13063-016-1177-8.
Multimorbidity is increasing in aging populations with a corresponding increase in polypharmacy as well as inappropriate prescribing. Depending on definitions, 25-50 % of patients aged 75 years or older are exposed to at least five drugs. Evidence is increasing that polypharmacy, even when guidelines advise the prescribing of each drug individually, can potentially cause more harm than benefit to older patients, due to factors such as drug-drug and drug-disease interactions. Several approaches reducing polypharmacy and inappropriate prescribing have been proposed, but evidence showing a benefit of these measures regarding clinically relevant endpoints is scarce. There is an urgent need to implement more effective strategies. We therefore set out to develop an evidence-based electronic decision support (eDS) tool to aid physicians in reducing inappropriate prescribing and test its effectiveness in a large-scale cluster-randomized controlled trial.
The "Polypharmacy in chronic diseases-Reduction of Inappropriate Medication and Adverse drug events in older populations" (PRIMA)-eDS tool is a tool comprising an indication check and recommendations for the reduction of polypharmacy and inappropriate prescribing based on systematic reviews and guidelines, the European list of inappropriate medications for older people, the SFINX-database of interactions, the PHARAO-database on adverse effects, and the RENBASE-database on renal dosing. The tool will be evaluated in a cluster-randomized controlled trial involving 325 general practitioners (GPs) and around 3500 patients across five study centres in the United Kingdom, Germany, Austria and Italy. GP practices will be asked to recruit 11 patients aged 75 years or older who are taking at least eight medications and will be cluster-randomized after completion of patient recruitment. Intervention GPs will have access to the PRIMA-eDS tool, while control GPs will treat their patients according to current guidelines (usual care) without access to the PRIMA-eDS tool. After an observation time of 2 years, intervention and control groups will be compared regarding the primary composite endpoint of first non-elective hospitalization or death.
The principal hypothesis is that reduction of polypharmacy and inappropriate prescribing can improve the clinical composite outcome of hospitalization or death. A positive result of the trial will contribute substantially to the improvement of care in multimorbidity. The trial is necessary to investigate not only whether the reduction of polypharmacy improves outcome, but also whether GPs and patients are willing to follow the recommendations of the PRIMA-eDS tool.
This trial has been registered with Current Controlled Trials Ltd. on 31 July 2014 (ISRCTN10137559).
在老龄化人群中,多种疾病并存的情况日益增多,同时多重用药及不适当处方也相应增加。根据不同定义,25%至50%的75岁及以上患者至少服用五种药物。越来越多的证据表明,即使指南建议单独开具每种药物,多重用药由于药物相互作用和药物与疾病相互作用等因素,对老年患者可能造成的危害大于益处。已经提出了几种减少多重用药和不适当处方的方法,但关于这些措施在临床相关终点方面显示出益处的证据很少。迫切需要实施更有效的策略。因此,我们着手开发一种基于证据的电子决策支持(eDS)工具,以帮助医生减少不适当处方,并在一项大规模整群随机对照试验中测试其有效性。
“慢性病中的多重用药——减少老年人群不适当用药和药物不良事件”(PRIMA)-eDS工具是一种工具,它基于系统评价和指南、欧洲老年人不适当用药清单、SFINX相互作用数据库、PHARAO不良反应数据库以及RENBASE肾脏给药数据库,包括适应症检查和减少多重用药及不适当处方的建议。该工具将在一项整群随机对照试验中进行评估,该试验涉及英国、德国、奥地利和意大利五个研究中心的325名全科医生(GP)和约3500名患者。GP诊所将被要求招募11名75岁及以上且至少服用八种药物的患者,并在完成患者招募后进行整群随机分组。干预组的GP可以使用PRIMA-eDS工具,而对照组的GP将根据现行指南(常规护理)治疗患者,无法使用PRIMA-eDS工具。经过2年的观察期后,将比较干预组和对照组在首次非选择性住院或死亡的主要复合终点方面的情况。
主要假设是减少多重用药和不适当处方可以改善住院或死亡的临床复合结局。试验的阳性结果将对改善多种疾病并存情况下的护理有很大贡献。该试验不仅有必要研究减少多重用药是否能改善结局,还需研究GP和患者是否愿意遵循PRIMA-eDS工具的建议。
该试验已于2014年7月31日在Current Controlled Trials Ltd.注册(ISRCTN10137559)。