Gimondi Ilaria, Cavallotti Carlo, Vanuzzo Gianmarco, Balucani Nadia, Casavecchia Piergiorgio
Politecnico di Milano, Dipartimento di Chimica, Materiali e Ingegneria Chimica "Giulio Natta" , 20131 Milano, Italy.
Dipartimento di Chimica, Biologia e Biotecnologie, Università degli Studi di Perugia , 06123 Perugia, Italy.
J Phys Chem A. 2016 Jul 14;120(27):4619-33. doi: 10.1021/acs.jpca.6b01564. Epub 2016 Apr 13.
The mechanism of the O((3)P) + CH3CCH reaction was investigated using a combined experimental/theoretical approach. Experimentally the reaction dynamics was studied using crossed molecular beams (CMB) with mass-spectrometric detection and time-of-flight analysis at 9.2 kcal/mol collision energy. Theoretically master equation (ME) simulations were performed on a potential energy surface (PES) determined using high-level ab initio electronic structure calculations. In this paper (II) the theoretical results are described and compared with experiments, while in paper (I) are reported and discussed the results of the experimental study. The PES was investigated by determining structures and vibrational frequencies of wells and transition states at the CASPT2/aug-cc-pVTZ level using a minimal active space. Energies were then determined at the CASPT2 level increasing systematically the active space and at the CCSD(T) level extrapolating to the complete basis set limit. Two separate portions of the triplet PES were investigated, as O((3)P) can add either on the terminal or the central carbon of the unsaturated propyne bond. Minimum energy crossing points (MECPs) between the triplet and singlet PESs were searched at the CASPT2 level. The calculated spin-orbit coupling constants between the T1 and S0 electronic surfaces were ∼25 cm(-1) for both PESs. The portions of the singlet PES that can be accessed from the MECPs were investigated at the same level of theory. The system reactivity was predicted integrating stochastically the one-dimensional ME using Rice-Ramsperger-Kassel-Marcus theory to determine rate constants on the full T1/S0 PESs, accounting explicitly for intersystem crossing (ISC) using the Landau-Zener model. The computational results are compared both with the branching ratios (BRs) determined experimentally in the companion paper (I) and with those estimated in a recent kinetic study at 298 K. The ME results allow to interpret the main system reactivity: CH3CCO + H and CH3 + HCCO are the major channels active on the triplet PES and are formed from the wells accessed after O addition to the terminal and central C, respectively; (1)CH3CH + CO and C2H3 + HCO are the major channels active on the singlet PES and are formed from the methylketene and acrolein wells after ISC. However, also a large number of minor channels (∼15) are active, so that the system reactivity is quite complicated. The comparison between computational and experimental BRs is quite good for the kinetic study, while some discrepancy with the CMB estimations suggests that dynamic non-ergodic effects may influence the system reactivity. Channel specific rate constants are calculated in the 300-2250 K and 1-30 bar temperature and pressure ranges. It is found that as the temperature increases the H abstraction reaction, whose contribution is negligible in the experimental conditions, increases in relevance, and the extent of ISC decreases from ∼80% at 300 K to less than 2% at 2250 K.
采用实验与理论相结合的方法研究了O((3)P) + CH3CCH反应的机理。实验上,利用交叉分子束(CMB)结合质谱检测和飞行时间分析,在9.2 kcal/mol的碰撞能量下研究了反应动力学。理论上,在使用高水平从头算电子结构计算确定的势能面(PES)上进行了主方程(ME)模拟。在本文(II)中描述了理论结果并与实验进行了比较,而在论文(I)中报告并讨论了实验研究的结果。通过在最小活性空间下使用CASPT2/aug-cc-pVTZ水平确定阱和过渡态的结构及振动频率来研究PES。然后在CASPT2水平上通过系统增加活性空间并在CCSD(T)水平上外推到完整基组极限来确定能量。研究了三重态PES的两个独立部分,因为O((3)P)可以加成到不饱和丙炔键的末端或中心碳原子上。在CASPT2水平上搜索了三重态和单重态PES之间的最小能量交叉点(MECP)。两个PES的T1和S0电子表面之间计算得到的自旋 - 轨道耦合常数约为25 cm(-1)。在相同理论水平下研究了可从MECP进入的单重态PES部分。使用Rice - Ramsperger - Kassel - Marcus理论对一维ME进行随机积分来预测系统反应性,以确定完整T1/S0 PES上的速率常数,并使用Landau - Zener模型明确考虑系间窜越(ISC)。将计算结果与在配套论文(I)中实验测定的分支比(BR)以及最近在298 K下的动力学研究中估计的分支比进行了比较。ME结果有助于解释主要的系统反应性:CH3CCO + H和CH3 + HCCO是三重态PES上的主要活性通道,分别由O加成到末端和中心C后进入的阱形成;(1)CH3CH + CO和C2H3 + HCO是单重态PES上的主要活性通道,由ISC后的甲基乙烯酮和丙烯醛阱形成。然而,也有大量次要通道(约15个)是活跃的,因此系统反应性相当复杂。计算和实验BR之间的比较对于动力学研究相当吻合,而与CMB估计值存在一些差异,这表明动态非遍历效应可能影响系统反应性。在300 - 2250 K和1 - 30 bar的温度和压力范围内计算了通道特定的速率常数。发现随着温度升高,在实验条件下贡献可忽略不计的氢提取反应的相关性增加,ISC的程度从300 K时的约80%降至2250 K时的小于2%。