Turner R Jay, Thomas Courtney S, Brown Tyson H
Vanderbilt University, USA.
University of Kentucky, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2016 May;156:114-24. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2016.02.026. Epub 2016 Feb 26.
Substantial evidence has accumulated supporting a causal link between childhood adversity and risk for poor health years and even decades later. One interpretation of this evidence is that this linkage arises largely or exclusively from a process of biological embedding that is not modifiable by subsequent social context or experience - implying childhood as perhaps the only point at which intervention efforts are likely to be effective. This paper considers the extent to which this long-term association arises from intervening differences in social context and/or environmental experiences - a finding that would suggest that post-childhood prevention efforts may also be effective. Based on the argument that the selected research definition of adult health status may have implications for the early adversity-adult health linkage, we use a representative community sample of black and white adults (N = 1252) to evaluate this relationship across three health indices: doctor diagnosed illnesses, self-rated health, and allostatic load. Results generally indicate that observed relationships between childhood adversity and dimensions of adult health status were totally or almost totally accounted for by variations in adult socioeconomic position (SEP) and adult stress exposure. One exception is the childhood SEP-allostatic load association, for which a statistically significant relationship remained in the context of adult stress and SEP. This lone finding supports a conclusion that the impact of childhood adversity is not always redeemable by subsequent experience. However, in general, analyses suggest the likely utility of interventions beyond childhood aimed at reducing exposure to social stress and improving social and economic standing. Whatever the effects on adult health that derive from biological embedding, they appear to be primarily indirect effects through adult social context and exposure.
大量证据不断积累,支持童年逆境与多年甚至几十年后健康状况不佳风险之间存在因果联系。对这一证据的一种解释是,这种联系很大程度上或完全源于一种生物嵌入过程,这种过程不会因随后的社会环境或经历而改变——这意味着童年可能是干预措施可能有效的唯一阶段。本文探讨了这种长期关联在多大程度上源于社会环境和/或环境经历的干预差异——这一发现表明童年后预防措施也可能有效。基于所选的成人健康状况研究定义可能对早期逆境与成人健康联系有影响这一论点,我们使用一个具有代表性的黑人和白人成年人社区样本(N = 1252),通过三个健康指标来评估这种关系:医生诊断的疾病、自评健康和应激负荷。结果总体表明,童年逆境与成人健康状况维度之间观察到的关系完全或几乎完全由成人社会经济地位(SEP)和成人压力暴露的差异所解释。一个例外是童年SEP与应激负荷的关联,在成人压力和SEP的背景下,这种关联仍具有统计学意义。这一唯一发现支持了这样一个结论,即童年逆境的影响并非总是能被随后的经历所弥补。然而,总体而言,分析表明童年后旨在减少社会压力暴露和改善社会经济地位的干预措施可能有用。无论生物嵌入对成人健康有何种影响,它们似乎主要是通过成人社会环境和暴露产生的间接影响。