Hermans S M, Andrews J R, Bekker L-G, Wood R
Desmond Tutu HIV Centre, Institute for Infectious Diseases and Molecular Medicine, University of Cape Town, South Africa; Department of Global Health, Academic Medical Center, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam Institute for Global Health and Development, Netherlands; Department of Internal Medicine, School of Medicine, Makerere University College of Health Sciences, Kampala, Uganda.
S Afr Med J. 2016 Dec 1;106(12):1263-1269. doi: 10.7196/SAMJ.2016.v106.i12.10744.
Tuberculosis (TB) control programmes rely mainly on passive detection of symptomatic individuals. The resurgence of TB has rekindled interest in active case finding. Cape Town (South Africa) had a mass miniature radiography (MMR) screening programme from 1948 to 1994.
To evaluate screening coverage, yield and secular trends in TB notifications during the MMR programme.
We performed an ecological analysis of the MMR programme and TB notification data from the City of Cape Town Medical Officer of Health reports for 1948 - 1994.
Between 1948 and 1962, MMR screening increased to 12% of the population per annum with yields of 14 cases per 1 000 X-rays performed, accounting for >20% of total annual TB notifications. Concurrent with increasing coverage (1948 - 1965), TB case notification decreased in the most heavily TB-burdened non-European population from 844/100 000 population to 415/100 000. After 1966, coverage declined and TB notifications that initially remained stable (1967 - 1978) subsequently increased to 525/100 000. MMR yields remained low in the European population but declined rapidly in the non-European population after 1966, coincidental with forced removals from District 6. An inverse relationship between screening coverage and TB notification rates was observed in the non-European adult population. Similar secular trends occurred in infants and young children who were not part of the MMR screening programme.
MMR of a high-burdened population may have significantly contributed to TB control and was temporally associated with decreased transmission to infants and children. These historical findings emphasise the importance of re-exploring targeted active case finding strategies as part of population TB control.
结核病控制项目主要依赖对有症状个体的被动检测。结核病的再度流行重新引发了对主动病例发现的兴趣。1948年至1994年期间,开普敦(南非)实施了大规模微型放射摄影(MMR)筛查项目。
评估MMR项目期间的筛查覆盖率、检出率以及结核病通报的长期趋势。
我们对MMR项目以及开普敦市卫生官员1948 - 1994年报告中的结核病通报数据进行了生态分析。
1948年至1962年间,MMR筛查每年覆盖人口比例增至12%,每进行1000次X光检查的检出率为14例,占年度结核病通报总数的20%以上。在覆盖率上升期间(1948 - 1965年),结核病负担最重的非欧洲人群中的病例通报率从每10万人口844例降至415例。1966年后,覆盖率下降,结核病通报最初保持稳定(1967 - 1978年),随后增至每10万人口525例。欧洲人群中的MMR检出率一直较低,但1966年后非欧洲人群中的检出率迅速下降,这与从六区强制搬迁的情况同时发生。在非欧洲成年人群中观察到筛查覆盖率与结核病通报率之间呈负相关。未参与MMR筛查项目的婴幼儿也出现了类似的长期趋势。
对高负担人群进行MMR筛查可能对结核病控制做出了重大贡献,并且在时间上与减少向婴幼儿的传播相关。这些历史发现强调了重新探索有针对性的主动病例发现策略作为人群结核病控制一部分的重要性。