Prielipp Richard C, Weinkauf Julia L, Esser Thomas M, Thomas Brian J, Warner Mark A
From the *University of Minnesota Medical School, Minneapolis, Minnesota; †Preferred Physicians Medical, Overland Park, Kansas; and ‡Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota.
Anesth Analg. 2017 Sep;125(3):846-851. doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000002125.
Patient safety secured by constant vigilance remains a primary responsibility of every anesthesia professional. Although significant attention has been focused on patient falls occurring before and after surgery, a potentially catastrophic complication is when patients fall off an operating room or procedure table during anesthesia care. Because such events are (fortunately) uncommon, and because very little information is published in our literature, we queried 2 independent closed claims databases (the American Society of Anesthesiologists Closed Claims Project and the secure records of a private, anesthesia specialty-specific liability insurer) for information. We acquired documentation of patient events where a fall occurred during anesthesia care, noting the surrounding conditions of the provider, the patient, and the environment at the time of the event. We identified 21 claims (1.2% of cases) from the American Society of Anesthesiologists Closed Claims Project, while information from a private liability insurer identified falls in only 0.07% of cases. The percentage of these patients under general, regional, or monitored anesthesia care anesthesia was 71.5%, 19.5%, and 9.5%, respectively. To educate personnel about these uncommon events, we summarized this cohort with illustrative examples in a series of mini-case reports, noting that both inpatients and outpatients undergoing a broad array of procedures with various anesthetic techniques within and outside operating rooms may be vulnerable to patient falls. Based on detailed reports, we created 2 supplementary videos to further illuminate some of the unique mechanisms by which these events and their resulting injuries occur. When such information was available, we also noted the associated liability costs of defending and settling malpractice claims associated with these events. Our goal is to inform anesthesia and perioperative personnel about the common patient, provider, and environmental risk factors that appear to contribute to these mishaps, and suggest key strategies to mitigate the risks.
通过持续警惕确保患者安全仍然是每位麻醉专业人员的首要责任。尽管人们已将大量注意力集中在手术前后患者跌倒的问题上,但在麻醉护理期间患者从手术室或手术台上跌落是一种潜在的灾难性并发症。由于此类事件(幸运的是)并不常见,且我们的文献中发表的相关信息极少,我们查询了两个独立的封闭索赔数据库(美国麻醉医师协会封闭索赔项目和一家专门针对麻醉专业的私人责任保险公司的安全记录)以获取信息。我们获取了麻醉护理期间发生跌倒的患者事件的文档,记录了事件发生时医护人员、患者及环境周围的情况。我们从美国麻醉医师协会封闭索赔项目中识别出21项索赔(占病例的1.2%),而一家私人责任保险公司的信息仅识别出0.07%的病例中有跌倒情况。这些接受全身麻醉、区域麻醉或监护麻醉护理的患者比例分别为71.5%、19.5%和9.5%。为了让工作人员了解这些罕见事件,我们在一系列小型病例报告中用示例对这组病例进行了总结,指出无论是住院患者还是门诊患者,在手术室内外接受各种麻醉技术的广泛手术时都可能容易发生患者跌倒。基于详细报告,我们制作了两个补充视频,以进一步阐明这些事件及其导致伤害发生的一些独特机制。当有此类信息时,我们还记录了与这些事件相关的医疗事故索赔辩护和和解的相关责任成本。我们的目标是告知麻醉和围手术期工作人员那些似乎导致这些不幸事件的常见患者、医护人员和环境风险因素,并提出降低风险的关键策略。