Avny Ohad, Teitelbaum Tatiana, Simon Moshe, Michnick Tatiana, Siman-Tov Maya
Clalit Health Services Jerusalem District, Department of Family Medicine Faculty of Medicine, Hebrew University, Jerusalem, Israel.
Talbieh Psychiatric Clinic, Clalit Health Services, Primary Care Clinics, Jerusalem, Israel.
Isr J Psychiatry Relat Sci. 2016;53(1):71-75.
A consultation model between primary care physicians and psychiatrists that has been in operation for 12 years in the Jerusalem district of the Clalit Health Services in Israel is evaluated. In this model psychiatrists provide consultations twice a month at the primary care clinic. All patients are referred by their family physicians. Communication between the psychiatric consultant and the referring physician is carried out by telephone, correspondence and staff meetings.
Evaluation of the psychiatric care consultation model in which a psychiatrist consults at the primary care clinic.
A questionnaire-based survey distributed to 17 primary care physicians in primary care clinics in Jerusalem in which a psychiatric consultant is present.
Almost all of the doctors (93%) responded that the consultation model was superior to the existing model of referral to a secondary psychiatric clinic alone and reduced the workload in caring for the referred patients. The quality of psychiatric care was correlated with the depression prevalence among patients referred for consultation at their clinic (r=0.530, p=0.035). In addition, correlation was demonstrated between primary care physicians impression of alleviation of care of patients and their impression of extent of the patients' cooperation with the consulting psychiatrist (r=0.679, p = 0.015) Conclusions: Very limited conclusions may be drawn from this questionnaire distributed to primary care physicians who were asked to assess psychiatric consultation in their clinic. Our conclusion could be influenced by the design and the actual distribution of the questionnaires by the consulting psychiatrist. Nevertheless answers to the questionnaire might imply that the consultation model of care between a psychiatric consultant and the primary care physician, where the patient's primary care physician takes a leading role in his psychiatric care, is perceived by family physicians as a good alternative to referral to a psychiatric clinic, especially when treating patients suffering from depression.
对以色列克拉利特医疗服务机构耶路撒冷地区已运行12年的基层医疗医生与精神科医生会诊模式进行评估。在该模式中,精神科医生每月在基层医疗诊所提供两次会诊。所有患者均由其家庭医生转诊。精神科会诊医生与转诊医生之间通过电话、信函及员工会议进行沟通。
评估精神科医生在基层医疗诊所进行会诊的精神科护理会诊模式。
向耶路撒冷设有精神科会诊医生的基层医疗诊所的17名基层医疗医生发放基于问卷的调查。
几乎所有医生(93%)都表示,该会诊模式优于仅将患者转诊至二级精神科诊所的现有模式,且减轻了照顾转诊患者的工作量。精神科护理质量与在其诊所转诊进行会诊的患者中抑郁症患病率相关(r = 0.530,p = 0.035)。此外,基层医疗医生对患者护理缓解情况的印象与他们对患者与会诊精神科医生合作程度的印象之间存在相关性(r = 0.679,p = 0.015)。结论:向被要求评估其诊所精神科会诊的基层医疗医生发放的这份问卷,能得出的结论非常有限。我们的结论可能会受到会诊精神科医生设计和实际发放问卷方式的影响。然而,问卷的答案可能意味着,在患者的基层医疗医生在其精神科护理中起主导作用的情况下,精神科会诊医生与基层医疗医生之间的护理会诊模式,被家庭医生视为转诊至精神科诊所的一个很好的替代方案,尤其是在治疗抑郁症患者时。