Jandová S, Pazour J
Technická univerzita v Liberci.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2018;85(1):57-61.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY Currently, operative treatment is preferred in dislocated calcaneal fractures. Most frequently used is the extended lateral approach, the disadvantage of which is the risk of early complications. Therefore, less invasive operative techniques are sought that would reduce the risk of such complications. The presented study aimed to compare the two different surgical approaches with respect to the restoration of gait stereotype using the objective pedobarography. We assume that the limited operative approach in osteosynthesis of intra-articular calcaneal fractures results in comparable or earlier restoration of gait stereotype with regard to temporal and dynamic parameters compared to the extended lateral approach. MATERIAL AND METHODS The research study comprised a total of 22 patients who underwent the surgical treatment of intra-articular calcaneal fractures, divided into two groups by the applied operative approach. The first group consisted of 10 patients treated with less invasive sinus tarsi operative approach (ST). For osteosynthesis a calcaneal nail (C-nail, Medin, CR) was used. The second group consisted of 12 patients, to whom extended lateral approach (EXT) was applied. For osteosynthesis a calcaneal plate 3.5 mm (DePuy Synthes, Switzerland) was used. Pedobarographic measurement using a tensometric platform was performed in all the patients, always six months post-operatively. Temporal and dynamic variables of the gait cycle during the interaction of the foot with the ground were monitored. RESULTS In the EXT group, significant differences between the injured and healthy foot were found in walking 6 months after the surgery in most of temporal and dynamic variables. The ST group, however, showed no significant differences between the values for the injured and healthy foot in most of temporal and dynamic variables. DISCUSSION Six months after the surgery, the patients continue to carefully load the heel, regardless of the selected surgical approach, due to which the pressure at this place is significantly reduced and tends to be transferred to the midfoot or forefoot. This finding corresponds with previous studies. The patients undergoing a less invasive surgical approach load both the operated and healthy feet. Also, with regards to temporal parameters, as early as 6 months after the surgery correct gait stereotype is restored under the heel in these patients. We believe this is achieved thanks to less pain due to a limited extent of the surgical approach. On the very contrary, the extended lateral approach can cause deterioration of conditions for the restoration of gait stereotype due to the presence of extensive scarring on the heel side with a limited mobility of talocalcaneal joint or also an impaired mobility of peroneal tendons outside the ankle bone. CONCLUSIONS Six months after the surgical treatment of calcaneal fractures changes still persist in gait stereotype. The analysis of temporal and dynamic gait parameters in the followed-up group of patients reveals that the limited sinus tarsisurgical approach results in an earlier restoration of gait stereotype compared to the extended lateral approach. A higher number of patients in the respective groups is necessary in order to obtain more general results. Key words:sinus tarsi; extended lateral approach; plantar pressure; force; contact time.
研究目的 目前,跟骨骨折脱位时手术治疗是首选方法。最常用的是外侧延长入路,其缺点是存在早期并发症的风险。因此,人们在寻求侵入性较小的手术技术以降低此类并发症的风险。本研究旨在使用客观的足压力描记法比较两种不同手术入路在恢复步态模式方面的差异。我们假设,与外侧延长入路相比,关节内跟骨骨折切开复位内固定术中有限的手术入路在时间和动态参数方面能带来相当或更早的步态模式恢复。材料与方法 本研究共纳入22例行关节内跟骨骨折手术治疗的患者,根据所采用的手术入路分为两组。第一组由10例采用侵入性较小的距下窦入路(ST)治疗的患者组成。使用跟骨钉(C钉,Medin,CR)进行内固定。第二组由12例采用外侧延长入路(EXT)的患者组成。使用3.5mm跟骨钢板(DePuy Synthes,瑞士)进行内固定。所有患者均在术后6个月使用张力测量平台进行足压力描记测量。监测足部与地面接触时步态周期的时间和动态变量。结果 在EXT组中,术后6个月行走时,患足与健足在大多数时间和动态变量上存在显著差异。然而,ST组中患足与健足在大多数时间和动态变量的值上无显著差异。讨论 术后6个月,无论选择何种手术入路,患者仍会小心地负重足跟,因此该部位的压力显著降低,并倾向于转移至中足或前足。这一发现与先前的研究一致。接受侵入性较小手术入路的患者,患足和健足均会负重。此外,就时间参数而言,这些患者术后6个月足跟下即可恢复正确的步态模式。我们认为这得益于手术入路范围有限,疼痛较轻。相反,外侧延长入路可能会导致步态模式恢复情况恶化,因为足跟侧存在广泛瘢痕,距下关节活动受限,或者踝关节外侧腓骨肌腱活动也受损。结论 跟骨骨折手术治疗6个月后,步态模式仍存在变化。对随访患者的时间和动态步态参数分析表明,与外侧延长入路相比,有限的距下窦手术入路能更早恢复步态模式。为获得更具普遍性的结果,各研究组需要纳入更多患者。关键词:距下窦;外侧延长入路;足底压力;力;接触时间