Nuffield Department of Women's & Reproductive Health, University of Oxford, John Radcliffe Hospital, Headington, Oxford, OX3 9DU, UK.
Centre for Statistics in Medicine, Botnar Research Centre, Nuffield Department of Orthopaedics, Rheumatology and Musculoskeletal Sciences, University of Oxford, Windmill Road, Oxford, OX3 7LD, UK.
Stat Med. 2019 Aug 30;38(19):3527-3539. doi: 10.1002/sim.8000. Epub 2018 Oct 23.
This paper discusses the features of study design and methodological considerations for constructing reference centile charts for attained size, growth, and velocity charts with a focus on human growth charts used during pregnancy. Recent systematic reviews of pregnancy dating, fetal size, and newborn size charts showed that many studies aimed at constructing charts are still conducted poorly. Important design features such as inclusion and exclusion criteria, ultrasound quality control measures, sample size determination, anthropometric evaluation, gestational age estimation, assessment of outliers, and chart presentation are seldom well addressed, considered, or reported. Many of these charts are in clinical use today and directly affect the identification of at-risk newborns that require treatment and nutritional strategies. This paper therefore reiterates some of the concepts previously identified as important for growth studies, focusing on considerations and concepts related to study design, sample size, and methodological considerations with an aim of obtaining valid reference or standard centile charts. We discuss some of the key issues and provide more details and practical examples based on our experiences from the INTERGROWTH-21 Project. We discuss the statistical methodology and analyses for cross-sectional studies and longitudinal studies in a separate article in this issue.
本文讨论了构建获得性大小、生长和速度图表参考百分位数图表的研究设计特点和方法学考虑因素,重点关注妊娠期间使用的人类生长图表。最近对妊娠日期、胎儿大小和新生儿大小图表的系统评价表明,许多旨在构建图表的研究仍然做得很差。重要的设计特点,如纳入和排除标准、超声质量控制措施、样本量确定、人体测量评估、胎龄估计、异常值评估和图表呈现,很少得到很好的解决、考虑或报告。如今,许多这些图表都在临床应用中,直接影响到需要治疗和营养策略的高危新生儿的识别。因此,本文重申了一些之前被认为对生长研究很重要的概念,重点关注与研究设计、样本量和方法学考虑因素相关的概念,目的是获得有效的参考或标准百分位数图表。我们讨论了一些关键问题,并根据我们在 INTERGROWTH-21 项目中的经验提供了更多详细信息和实际示例。我们在本期的另一篇文章中讨论了横断面研究和纵向研究的统计方法和分析。