Krepela Josef, Hosak Ladislav, Pachlova Barbora, Hrdlicka Michal
Psychiatric Hospital, Havlickuv Brod, Czech Republic.
Psychiatr Danub. 2019 Mar;31(1):62-68. doi: 10.24869/psyd.2019.62.
The aim of our retrospective naturalistic observational study was to describe the use of maintenance electroconvulsive therapy (M-ECT) in chronic pharmacoresistant schizophrenia.
We delineated 19 cases of chronic pharmacoresistant schizophrenia (females N=12) recently treated with maintenance electroconvulsive therapy at the Havlickuv Brod Psychiatric Hospital in the Czech Republic. Demographic, clinical and treatment variables were recorded.
M-ECT, when applied weekly to monthly mostly over a period of several years, was of no benefit in the treatment of chronic hallucinations and/or delusions. However, it did prove beneficial (p<0.001) in removing chronic serious symptoms like suicidal or violent behavior, automutilation, refusal of food or liquids, stupor or catatonia. Even though almost all of our patients remained hospitalized, we were nonetheless able to transfer them to an unlocked psychiatric ward and let them out for walks or occupational therapy with almost no need for using restraint. No serious adverse side effects of M-ECT were found.
Our study is limited by using only one simple standardized measurement (Clinical Global Impression - Severity) that was retrospective. Another limitation of our retrospective study was that the subjects had not been regularly tested for their cognitive functions. According to our results, M-ECT mitigates the impact of the disease and improves social functioning of the patients. M-ECT does not treat chronic schizophrenia but does make the lives of patients more tolerable. We suggest further research into M-ECT and its clinical application in chronic pharmacoresistant schizophrenia.
我们这项回顾性自然观察研究的目的是描述维持性电休克治疗(M-ECT)在慢性药物抵抗性精神分裂症中的应用。
我们划定了19例慢性药物抵抗性精神分裂症患者(女性12例),这些患者近期在捷克共和国哈夫利奇库夫布罗德精神病院接受了维持性电休克治疗。记录了人口统计学、临床和治疗变量。
M-ECT在数年时间里大多每周至每月应用一次,对治疗慢性幻觉和/或妄想并无益处。然而,在消除慢性严重症状如自杀或暴力行为、自残、拒食或拒液、木僵或紧张症方面,它确实证明是有益的(p<0.001)。尽管几乎所有患者仍住院,但我们仍能够将他们转到无锁闭的精神科病房,让他们外出散步或接受职业治疗,几乎无需使用约束措施。未发现M-ECT有严重不良副作用。
我们的研究存在局限性,仅采用了一种简单的标准化回顾性测量方法(临床总体印象-严重程度)。我们回顾性研究的另一个局限性是,未对受试者进行认知功能的定期检测。根据我们的结果,M-ECT减轻了疾病的影响,改善了患者的社会功能。M-ECT不能治疗慢性精神分裂症,但确实使患者的生活更易忍受。我们建议对M-ECT及其在慢性药物抵抗性精神分裂症中的临床应用进行进一步研究。