Gajjar Prachi Chetankumar, Mehta Hita Hemant, Barvaliya Manish, Sonagra Bhavesh
Department of Dermatology, Government Medical College, Bhavnagar, Gujarat, India.
Department of Pharmacology, Government Medical College, Bhavnagar, Gujarat, India.
Int J Trichology. 2019 Mar-Apr;11(2):58-67. doi: 10.4103/ijt.ijt_89_18.
This study aims to compare efficacy and safety between mesotherapy (intralesional injection) and 5% topical minoxidil solution in male androgenic alopecia (AGA) by dermoscopic evaluation.
In a randomized active controlled trial, we enrolled 49 clinically diagnosed males of AGA and randomly allotted them into two groups - mesotherapy (A) (25) and minoxidil (B) (24). Males in Group A were given total 8 sessions of intralesional mesosolution with microneedling procedure while Group B males were prescribed topical solution of minoxidil 5% twice daily for 4 months. Results were evaluated at baseline and then monthly for 4 months with clinical photographs, dermoscopy, trichoscan, 7-point standard assessment tool, and patient-self assessment scores.
Grade II was the most common presentation in our study. All dermoscopic parameters such as variation of hair shaft diameter, follicular units with single and multiple hairs, yellow dots, and perifollicular halo did not show any significant difference between the groups at all time points except at 1 month where the difference in variation of hair shaft diameter between the two group was 0.04. We observed a significant increase ( = 0.01) in the variation of hair shaft diameter between pre- and post-treatment in mesotherapy group compared to minoxidil group. The rest of parameters failed to show any significant difference within the group in mesotherapy and minoxidil.
In our study, we observed a significant increase in the variation of hair shaft diameter between pre- and post-treatment in Group A compared to B. Other dermoscopic, trichoscan, and subjective measurement tool failed to show significant difference between two groups. Our observation suggests that there is no significant improvement of mesotherapy in male AGA over minoxidil.
本研究旨在通过皮肤镜评估比较中胚层疗法(病灶内注射)与5%外用米诺地尔溶液治疗男性雄激素性脱发(AGA)的疗效和安全性。
在一项随机活性对照试验中,我们纳入了49例临床诊断为AGA的男性,并将他们随机分为两组——中胚层疗法组(A组)(25例)和米诺地尔组(B组)(24例)。A组男性接受总共8次微针中胚层溶液病灶内注射,而B组男性被开了5%的米诺地尔外用溶液,每天两次,持续4个月。在基线时进行结果评估,然后在4个月内每月进行评估,采用临床照片、皮肤镜检查、毛发扫描、7分标准评估工具和患者自我评估分数。
II级是我们研究中最常见的表现。所有皮肤镜参数,如毛干直径变化、单根和多根毛发的毛囊单位、黄点和毛囊周晕,在所有时间点两组之间均未显示出任何显著差异,但在1个月时,两组之间毛干直径变化的差异为0.04。与米诺地尔组相比,我们观察到中胚层疗法组治疗前后毛干直径变化有显著增加(P = 0.01)。中胚层疗法组和米诺地尔组的其他参数在组内未显示出任何显著差异。
在我们的研究中,我们观察到与B组相比,A组治疗前后毛干直径变化有显著增加。其他皮肤镜、毛发扫描和主观测量工具在两组之间未显示出显著差异。我们的观察表明,中胚层疗法在男性AGA治疗中相对于米诺地尔没有显著改善。