Mele Bria, Goodarzi Zahra, Hanson Heather M, Holroyd-Leduc Jayna
Department of Community Health Sciences, University of Calgary, Foothills Medical Centre, South Tower, Room 1104, 1403-29 St. NW, Calgary, AB, T2N 2T9, Canada.
Department of Medicine, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
BMC Neurol. 2019 May 24;19(1):101. doi: 10.1186/s12883-019-1329-z.
Apathy is a prominent non-motor symptom in Parkinson's disease (PD). People with apathy show a lack of emotion, passion, and motivation. Between 17 and 70% of persons with PD have apathy; the extreme heterogeneity in these estimates is due to limited heterogeneous knowledge concerning how to diagnose PD. The lack of a widely utilized diagnostic process limits understandings on how to treat and manage apathy in PD. A scoping review of apathy in PD identified only one qualitative study investigating this symptom. It was our objective to assess perceived barriers and facilitators to diagnosing, treating, and managing apathy in PD, as described by key stakeholders.
This research applied qualitative methodology, utilizing focus groups and interviews with health care practitioners (HCPs), persons with PD, and caregivers. Evidence gathered from a scoping review on apathy in PD informed discussions that took place with participants. Data collection and analysis was conducted using framework analysis, applying the Theoretical Domains Framework and Behaviour Change Wheel.
Eleven HCPs and five persons with PD/caregivers participated. Themes included interdisciplinary teams and communication with family to facilitate diagnosis and treatment, and the use of education and increased awareness of apathy to facilitate management. Themes surrounding barriers included lack of initiative and motivation to maintain treatment plans, and a lack of evidence for apathy specific interventions. While a key barrier identified was the lack of information HCPs have access to, persons with PD and caregivers would prefer to receive a diagnosis of apathy even with limited management methods. Thus, education and awareness were noted as two of the most important facilitators, overall.
These findings suggest that diagnosing, treating, and managing apathy in PD requires interdisciplinary teams, that include family and caregivers. We identified that where HCPs perceive lack of knowledge as a barrier to diagnosis, persons with PD and caregivers find being given a diagnosis facilitates understanding. These findings highlight the importance of qualitative research involving persons with PD and apathy, caregivers, and HCPs who aid in management of this symptom. Barriers reported suggest future research must aim to identify apathy specific treatments, both pharmacologic and non-pharmacologic.
冷漠是帕金森病(PD)中一种突出的非运动症状。冷漠的人表现出缺乏情感、热情和动力。17%至70%的帕金森病患者存在冷漠症状;这些估计值的极端异质性是由于关于如何诊断帕金森病的知识有限且存在异质性。缺乏广泛应用的诊断流程限制了对如何治疗和管理帕金森病冷漠症状的理解。一项关于帕金森病冷漠症状的范围综述仅发现了一项调查该症状的定性研究。我们的目标是评估关键利益相关者所描述的帕金森病冷漠症状诊断、治疗和管理中的感知障碍及促进因素。
本研究采用定性方法,利用焦点小组以及对医疗保健从业者(HCPs)、帕金森病患者及其护理人员进行访谈。从关于帕金森病冷漠症状的范围综述中收集的证据为与参与者进行的讨论提供了信息。数据收集和分析采用框架分析法,应用理论领域框架和行为改变轮。
11名医疗保健从业者以及5名帕金森病患者/护理人员参与了研究。主题包括跨学科团队以及与家人沟通以促进诊断和治疗,以及利用教育和提高对冷漠症状的认识来促进管理。围绕障碍的主题包括缺乏维持治疗计划的主动性和动力,以及缺乏针对冷漠症状的特定干预措施的证据。虽然确定的一个关键障碍是医疗保健从业者可获取的信息不足,但即使管理方法有限,帕金森病患者及其护理人员仍希望得到冷漠症状的诊断。因此,总体而言,教育和认识被认为是两个最重要的促进因素。
这些发现表明,帕金森病冷漠症状的诊断、治疗和管理需要跨学科团队,其中包括患者家属和护理人员。我们发现,当医疗保健从业者将知识缺乏视为诊断障碍时,帕金森病患者及其护理人员认为得到诊断有助于理解。这些发现凸显了涉及帕金森病患者、冷漠症状患者、护理人员以及协助管理该症状的医疗保健从业者的定性研究的重要性。所报告的障碍表明,未来的研究必须致力于确定针对冷漠症状的特定治疗方法,包括药物治疗和非药物治疗。