Office of Clinical Pharmacology, Center for Drug Evaluation and Research, U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Silver Spring, Maryland, 20903, USA.
AAPS J. 2019 Jun 3;21(4):72. doi: 10.1208/s12248-019-0339-5.
Systems pharmacology approaches have the capability of quantitatively linking the key biological molecules relevant to a drug candidate's mechanism of action (drug-induced signaling pathways) to the clinical biomarkers associated with the proposed target disease, thereby quantitatively facilitating its development and life cycle management. In this review, the model attributes of published quantitative systems pharmacology (QSP) modeling for lowering cholesterol, treating salt-sensitive hypertension, and treating rare diseases as well as describing bone homeostasis and related pharmacological effects are critically reviewed with respect to model quality, calibration, validation, and performance. We further reviewed the common practices in optimizing QSP modeling and prediction. Notably, leveraging genetics and genomic studies for model calibration and validation is common. Statistical and quantitative assessment of QSP prediction and handling of model uncertainty are, however, mostly lacking as are the quantitative and statistical criteria for assessing QSP predictions and the covariance matrix of coefficients between the parameters in a validated virtual population. To accelerate advances and application of QSP with consistent quality, a list of key questions is proposed to be addressed when assessing the quality of a QSP model in hopes of stimulating the scientific community to set common expectations. The common expectations as to what constitutes the best QSP modeling practices, which the scientific community supports, will advance QSP modeling in the realm of informed drug development. In the long run, good practices will extend the life cycles of QSP models beyond the life cycles of individual drugs.
系统药理学方法能够定量地将与候选药物作用机制(药物诱导的信号通路)相关的关键生物分子与与拟议靶疾病相关的临床生物标志物联系起来,从而定量地促进其开发和生命周期管理。在这篇综述中,我们批判性地回顾了已发表的用于降低胆固醇、治疗盐敏感性高血压和治疗罕见疾病的定量系统药理学(QSP)建模的模型属性,以及描述骨稳态和相关药理作用的模型属性,重点是模型质量、校准、验证和性能。我们进一步回顾了优化 QSP 建模和预测的常见实践。值得注意的是,利用遗传学和基因组研究进行模型校准和验证是常见的。然而,QSP 预测的统计和定量评估以及模型不确定性的处理在很大程度上仍然缺乏,缺乏用于评估 QSP 预测的定量和统计标准以及在经过验证的虚拟人群中参数之间的系数协方差矩阵。为了以一致的质量加速 QSP 的进展和应用,提出了一系列关键问题,以期望在评估 QSP 模型的质量时解决这些问题,希望能激发科学界设定共同的期望。科学界支持的关于最佳 QSP 建模实践的共同期望将推进知情药物开发领域的 QSP 建模。从长远来看,良好的实践将使 QSP 模型的生命周期超出单个药物的生命周期。