Gazitt Tal, Oren Shirley, Reitblat Tatiana, Lidar Merav, Gurman Alexandra Balbir, Rosner Itzhak, Halabe Nimer, Feld Joy, Kassem Sameer, Lavi Idit, Elkayam Ori, Zisman Devy
Department of Rheumatology, Carmel Medical Center, Haifa, Israel.
Department of Rheumatology, Rabin Medical Center, Petah Tikva, Israel.
Eur J Rheumatol. 2019 May 20;6(3):136-141. doi: 10.5152/eurjrheum.2019.18195. Print 2019 Jul.
We aimed to assess the implementation of the treat-to-target (T2T) concept in rheumatoid arthritis (RA) patients in daily practice.
All RA patients visiting one of the 7 academic medical centers in Israel in June 2015 with at least 3 previous clinic visits were included in this study. A common questionnaire was used to collect data from patients' medical records, and two independent rheumatologists evaluated the collected data for the implementation of the T2T concept. The associations between T2T implementation and the categorical and continuous variables were assessed.
The study included 724 patients with a mean (standard deviation) age of 62.6 (13.97) years and 575 (80.4%) of them were women. Four centers used more than one scoring method, with Disease Activity Score-28 and Clinical Disease Activity Index) being most commonly used. Only 276 (38.1%) patients had disease score results in ≥3 visits, and the T2T recommendations were implemented for 245 (33.8%) of the 724 patients. The rate of implementation was higher in younger (p=0.028) rheumatoid factor-positive patients (p=0.011) and varied between centers (11.1%-87% p<0.0001). T2T implementation did not correlate to gender, place of residence, education, tobacco use, treatment regimens, and presence of erosions or comorbidities.
The T2T concept was implemented on only 33.8% of patients and was not affected by RA disease severity. Further studies are needed to determine the reasons for this deviation from the T2T standard of care for RA as well as its consequences.
我们旨在评估在日常实践中类风湿关节炎(RA)患者的治疗达标(T2T)概念的实施情况。
纳入2015年6月就诊于以色列7家学术医疗中心之一且此前至少有3次门诊就诊记录的所有RA患者。使用通用问卷从患者病历中收集数据,两名独立的风湿病学家评估所收集的数据以确定T2T概念的实施情况。评估T2T实施与分类变量和连续变量之间的关联。
该研究纳入了724例患者,平均(标准差)年龄为62.6(13.97)岁,其中575例(80.4%)为女性。4个中心使用了不止一种评分方法,最常用的是疾病活动评分-28和临床疾病活动指数。只有276例(38.1%)患者在≥3次就诊时有疾病评分结果,724例患者中有245例(33.8%)实施了T2T推荐。在年龄较小的患者(p=0.028)、类风湿因子阳性的患者(p=0.011)中实施率较高,且各中心之间存在差异(11.1%-87%,p<0.0001)。T2T实施与性别、居住地点、教育程度、吸烟情况、治疗方案以及是否存在侵蚀或合并症无关。
T2T概念仅在33.8%的患者中得到实施,且不受RA疾病严重程度的影响。需要进一步研究以确定这种偏离RA T2T标准治疗的原因及其后果。