Shaw R Paul, Wang Hong, Kress Daniel, Hovig Dana
Independent Consultant ; Vancouver , British Columbia , Canada.
Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation ; Seattle , WA USA.
Health Syst Reform. 2015 Jan 2;1(1):72-88. doi: 10.1080/23288604.2014.996413.
-This paper evaluates resource commitments to primary health care (PHC) by donors and selected governments between 1990-2011. Donor commitments to financing PHC are assessed by reclassifying OECD/CRS data on health assistance into spending on 'PHC Service Delivery' versus spending on 'Health System Strengthening'. Domestic spending on PHC is assessed using a case study approach and National Health Accounts for two major recipients of donor assistance, Ethiopia and Nigeria. Results are generally consistent with three simple hypotheses that guide the inquiry. though donor funding for health among LICs has mushroomed over the last decade, it remains a miniscule share of per capita spending targets prescribed by international forums to attain universal access to basic/essential PHC services. Relative to levels of domestic spending in LICs, however, donor funding has considerably more significance as a potential lever to improve PHC efficiency. as reflected in on-going debate in the literature, donor spending on broader 'health system strengthening' has not kept up with mushrooming financing of disease control programs. at country level, where the 'rubber meets the road', allocative efficiency of donor and domestic spending on health is highly conditional on contextual factors, especially political will to improve financing and delivery of PHC services, and the process of managing and implementing public spending on PHC.
本文评估了1990年至2011年间捐助方和部分政府对初级卫生保健(PHC)的资源投入。通过将经合组织/发展援助委员会(OECD/CRS)关于卫生援助的数据重新分类为“初级卫生保健服务提供”支出和“卫生系统加强”支出,来评估捐助方对初级卫生保健融资的承诺。使用案例研究方法和国家卫生账户,对两个主要受援国埃塞俄比亚和尼日利亚的国内初级卫生保健支出进行了评估。结果总体上与指导该调查的三个简单假设一致。尽管过去十年中低收入国家(LICs)获得的卫生领域捐助资金迅速增加,但相对于国际论坛规定的实现全民基本/必需初级卫生保健服务覆盖的人均支出目标而言,这一资金仍占极小比例。然而,相对于低收入国家的国内支出水平,捐助资金作为提高初级卫生保健效率的潜在杠杆具有更大的重要性。正如文献中正在进行的辩论所反映的那样,捐助方在更广泛的“卫生系统加强”方面的支出未能跟上疾病控制项目迅速增加的融资。在国家层面,即实际行动层面,捐助方和国内在卫生方面的支出分配效率高度取决于背景因素,特别是改善初级卫生保健服务融资和提供的政治意愿,以及初级卫生保健公共支出的管理和实施过程。