Wagga Wagga Base Hospital, PO Box 159, Wagga Wagga, NSW 2650, Australia
Department of Rural Health, University of Melbourne, 49 Graham St, Shepparton, VIC 3630, Australia
Rural Remote Health. 2020 Aug;20(3):5668. doi: 10.22605/RRH5668. Epub 2020 Aug 31.
Longstanding gaps in physiotherapy service delivery exist in rural areas across Australia. In response to this, a large public rural health organisation contracted a private physiotherapy business to implement a public-private partnership (PPP) to supply physiotherapy to hospital inpatients, aged care facility residents and outpatients in four outer regional Australian towns. Treatment rooms were provided by the health organisation for the private physiotherapists to see clients. This study explored how stakeholders defined the success of a PPP model of service delivery in a rural setting and examined if the model was successful according to stakeholder definitions. Barriers and enablers (mechanisms) were identified and linked to stakeholder-defined success measures.
A qualitative study was conducted using a constructive inquiry design. Participants were purposively recruited, via email invitation and telephone follow-up. Participants comprised managers and clinicians from the rural public health organisation and the private physiotherapy business involved in setting up, working within or alongside the partnership. Semi-structured interviews were undertaken with all participants. Data were transcribed verbatim and analysed using framework analysis. Program logic was used to synthesise all information.
Individual interviews were conducted with five staff from each partnering organisation, including managers and clinicians (total n=10). Two main themes and three subthemes were identified. All participants described the model as being successful. Elements of success included improved access to local services, and satisfied stakeholders. There were three mechanisms identified to successfully implement the service delivery model. The first mechanism was the provision of human and several other resources, which included the workforce model and the use of several resources for the partnership. The second mechanism was stakeholder engagement, which included having motivated stakeholders and consistent stakeholders. The third mechanism was streamlined processes, which included the content of the contract and referral schedule, streamlined administration processes for contracting and accounting, having processes for managing private therapists in a public setting as well as processes for communication.
This study demonstrates that an innovative physiotherapy PPP model of service delivery can be a successful way to improve access to physiotherapy services in rural areas. Success of service models varies depending on the viewpoint of the stakeholder and achieving success for all stakeholders is contingent on mechanisms such as those identified in this study. PPPs have potential to address service gaps in hospitals, residential aged care and primary care in rural areas.
在澳大利亚农村地区,长期存在物理治疗服务提供方面的差距。为了解决这个问题,一个大型的农村公共卫生组织与一家私人物理治疗公司签订了一份公私合作伙伴关系(PPP)合同,为澳大利亚四个偏远地区城镇的医院住院患者、老年护理机构居民和门诊患者提供物理治疗服务。治疗室由卫生组织提供给私人物理治疗师为客户服务。本研究探讨了利益相关者如何定义农村环境中服务提供的 PPP 模式的成功,并根据利益相关者的定义检查了该模式是否成功。确定了障碍和促进因素(机制),并将其与利益相关者定义的成功措施联系起来。
采用建设性探究设计进行定性研究。通过电子邮件邀请和电话随访,有针对性地招募参与者。参与者包括参与建立、在伙伴关系中工作或与伙伴关系并行的农村公共卫生组织和私人物理治疗业务的经理和临床医生。对所有参与者进行了半结构化访谈。数据逐字转录,并使用框架分析进行分析。使用方案逻辑综合所有信息。
对每个合作组织的五名工作人员进行了个人访谈,包括经理和临床医生(共 10 人)。确定了两个主要主题和三个子主题。所有参与者都表示该模式取得了成功。成功的要素包括改善了对当地服务的获取,以及使利益相关者满意。确定了三个成功实施服务提供模式的机制。第一个机制是提供人力和其他几种资源,包括劳动力模式和为伙伴关系使用几种资源。第二个机制是利益相关者的参与,包括有积极性的利益相关者和一致的利益相关者。第三个机制是流程的简化,包括合同和转诊时间表的内容、简化签约和会计流程、在公共环境中管理私人治疗师的流程以及沟通流程。
本研究表明,创新的物理治疗 PPP 服务提供模式可以成为改善农村地区物理治疗服务获取的一种成功方式。服务模式的成功取决于利益相关者的观点,要使所有利益相关者都取得成功,取决于本研究中确定的机制等因素。公私合作伙伴关系有可能解决农村地区医院、老年护理和初级保健中的服务差距。