Anesthesiology. 2020 Dec 1;133(6):1214-1222. doi: 10.1097/ALN.0000000000003557.
The Hypotension Prediction Index is a commercially available algorithm, based on arterial waveform features, that predicts hypotension defined as mean arterial pressure less than 65 mmHg for at least 1 min. We therefore tested the primary hypothesis that index guidance reduces the duration and severity of hypotension during noncardiac surgery.
We enrolled adults having moderate- or high-risk noncardiac surgery with invasive arterial pressure monitoring. Participating patients were randomized to hemodynamic management with or without index guidance. Clinicians caring for patients assigned to guidance were alerted when the index exceeded 85 (range, 0 to 100) and a treatment algorithm based on advanced hemodynamic parameters suggested vasopressor administration, fluid administration, inotrope administration, or observation. Primary outcome was the amount of hypotension, defined as time-weighted average mean arterial pressure less than 65 mmHg. Secondary outcomes were time-weighted mean pressures less than 60 and 55 mmHg.
Among 214 enrolled patients, guidance was provided for 105 (49%) patients randomly assigned to the index guidance group. The median (first quartile, third quartile) time-weighted average mean arterial pressure less than 65 mmHg was 0.14 (0.03, 0.37) in guided patients versus 0.14 (0.03, 0.39) mmHg in unguided patients: median difference (95% CI) of 0 (-0.03 to 0.04), P = 0.757. Index guidance therefore did not reduce amount of hypotension less than 65 mmHg, nor did it reduce hypotension less than 60 or 55 mmHg. Post hoc, guidance was associated with less hypotension when analysis was restricted to episodes during which clinicians intervened.
In this pilot trial, index guidance did not reduce the amount of intraoperative hypotension. Half of the alerts were not followed by treatment, presumably due to short warning time, complex treatment algorithm, or clinicians ignoring the alert. In the future we plan to use a lower index alert threshold and a simpler treatment algorithm that emphasizes prompt treatment.
低血压预测指数是一种基于动脉波形特征的商业上可用的算法,用于预测至少 1 分钟内平均动脉压低于 65mmHg 的低血压。因此,我们检验了主要假设,即指数指导可减少非心脏手术期间低血压的持续时间和严重程度。
我们纳入了接受中度或高度非心脏手术并进行有创动脉压监测的成年人。参与的患者被随机分配到有或没有指数指导的血流动力学管理中。当指数超过 85(范围 0 到 100)时,负责照顾患者的临床医生会收到警报,并且基于先进的血流动力学参数的治疗算法建议使用血管加压药、液体、儿茶酚胺或观察。主要结局是定义为时间加权平均平均动脉压低于 65mmHg 的低血压量。次要结局是时间加权平均压力低于 60mmHg 和 55mmHg。
在 214 名入组患者中,105 名(49%)随机分配到指数指导组的患者接受了指导。指导患者的时间加权平均平均动脉压低于 65mmHg 的中位数(第一四分位数,第三四分位数)为 0.14(0.03,0.37)mmHg,未指导患者为 0.14(0.03,0.39)mmHg:中位数差值(95%CI)为 0(-0.03 至 0.04),P=0.757。因此,指数指导并没有减少低于 65mmHg 的低血压量,也没有减少低于 60mmHg 或 55mmHg 的低血压量。事后分析表明,当分析仅限于临床医生干预的发作时,指导与较少的低血压有关。
在这项试点试验中,指数指导并没有减少术中低血压的发生。一半的警报没有得到治疗,可能是由于警告时间短、治疗算法复杂或临床医生忽略了警报。未来我们计划使用较低的指数警报阈值和更简单的治疗算法,强调及时治疗。