Department of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, University of Groningen, University Medical Center Groningen, Groningen, the Netherlands.
Department of Psychology, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2022 Mar;31(3):483-493. doi: 10.1007/s00787-021-01735-4. Epub 2021 Feb 14.
Behavioral parent and teacher training and stimulant medication are recommended interventions for children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). However, not all children with ADHD receive this evidence-based care, and the aim of the current study was to find out why. More specifically, we investigated clinicians' policy, guideline use, and attitudes towards medication and parent training when treating children with ADHD, as well as several factors that could affect this. A total of 219 Dutch clinicians (mainly psychologists, psychiatrists and educationalists) completed a survey. Clinicians were likely to recommend medication more often than parent training, and clinicians' policy to recommend medication and parent training was positively associated with their attitudes towards these interventions. Less experienced clinicians and those with a non-medical background reported lower rates of guideline use, whereas clinicians with a medical background reported less positive attitudes towards parent training. Furthermore, a substantial portion of the clinicians based their decision to recommend parent training on their clinical judgement (e.g., prior estimations of efficacy, perceived low abilities/motivation of parents), and many clinicians reported barriers for referral to parent training, such as waiting lists or a lack of skilled staff. To achieve better implementation of evidence-based care for children with ADHD, guidelines should be communicated better towards clinicians. Researchers and policy-makers should further focus on barriers that prevent implementation of parent training, which are suggested by the discrepancy between clinicians' overall positive attitude towards parent training and the relatively low extent to which clinicians actually advise parent training.
行为父母和教师培训以及兴奋剂药物治疗被推荐用于治疗注意缺陷多动障碍(ADHD)儿童。然而,并非所有 ADHD 儿童都接受这种基于证据的护理,本研究旨在找出原因。更具体地说,我们调查了临床医生在治疗 ADHD 儿童时的政策、指南使用以及对药物治疗和家长培训的态度,以及可能影响这些态度的几个因素。共有 219 名荷兰临床医生(主要是心理学家、精神科医生和教育家)完成了一项调查。与家长培训相比,临床医生更倾向于推荐药物治疗,而临床医生推荐药物治疗和家长培训的政策与他们对这些干预措施的态度呈正相关。经验较少的临床医生和非医学背景的临床医生报告的指南使用频率较低,而具有医学背景的临床医生对家长培训的态度则不那么积极。此外,相当一部分临床医生根据他们的临床判断(例如,对疗效的先前估计、对父母能力/动机的感知较低)来决定推荐家长培训,许多临床医生报告了转介到家长培训的障碍,例如等待名单或缺乏熟练的工作人员。为了更好地为 ADHD 儿童实施基于证据的护理,应更好地向临床医生传达指南。研究人员和政策制定者应进一步关注阻碍家长培训实施的障碍,这些障碍是根据临床医生对家长培训的总体积极态度与他们实际建议家长培训的程度之间的差异提出的。