Feinstein Institutes for Medical Research at Northwell Health, New York, New York.
University of California, Los Angeles.
JAMA. 2022 Mar 22;327(12):1171-1176. doi: 10.1001/jama.2022.3267.
The US Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) works to improve the health of people nationwide by making evidence-based recommendations for preventive services. Patient-centered care is a core value in US health care. Shared decision-making (SDM), in which patients and clinicians make health decisions together, ensures patients' rights to be informed and involved in preventive care decisions and that these decisions are patient-centered. SDM has a role across the spectrum of USPSTF recommendations. For A or B recommendations (judged by the USPSTF to have high or moderate certainty of a moderate or substantial net benefit at the population level), SDM allows individual patients to decide whether to accept such services based on their personal values and preferences. For C recommendations (indicating at least moderate certainty of a small net benefit at the population level), SDM is critical for individual patients to decide whether the net benefit for them is worthwhile. For D recommendations (reflecting at least moderate certainty of a zero or negative net benefit) or I statements (low certainty of net benefit), clinicians should be prepared to discuss these services if patients ask. More evidence is needed to determine if, in addition to promoting patient-centeredness, SDM reduces inequities in preventive care, as well as to define new strategies to find time for discussion of preventive services in primary care.
美国预防服务工作组(USPSTF)致力于通过为预防服务制定基于证据的建议来改善全国人民的健康。以患者为中心的护理是美国医疗保健的核心价值观。共同决策(SDM)是指患者和临床医生共同做出健康决策,确保患者有权获得信息并参与预防保健决策,并且这些决策以患者为中心。SDM 在 USPSTF 建议的范围内发挥作用。对于 A 或 B 级推荐(USPSTF 判断在人群水平上具有中度或高度确定性,中等或实质性净收益),SDM 允许根据个人价值观和偏好,个别患者决定是否接受此类服务。对于 C 级推荐(表示在人群水平上至少有中度确定性的净收益较小),SDM 对于个别患者决定对他们来说净收益是否值得至关重要。对于 D 级推荐(反映至少有中度确定性的零或负净收益)或 I 声明(净收益的确定性较低),如果患者询问,临床医生应该准备好讨论这些服务。需要更多的证据来确定 SDM 是否除了促进以患者为中心之外,还可以减少预防保健方面的不平等,以及确定新的策略来寻找时间在初级保健中讨论预防服务。