Di Girolamo Chiara, Gnavi Roberto, Landriscina Tania, Forni Silvia, Falcone Manuele, Calandrini Enrico, Cesaroni Giulia, Russo Antonio, Leoni Olivia, Fanizza Caterina, Allotta Alessandra, Costa Giuseppe, Spadea Teresa
Regional Health and Social Care Agency Emilia-Romagna Region, Bologna, Italy
Epidemiology Unit, ASL TO3 Piedmont Region, Turin, Italy.
J Epidemiol Community Health. 2022 May 12. doi: 10.1136/jech-2021-218452.
The pandemic may undermine the equity of access to and utilisation of health services for conditions other than COVID-19. The objective of the study is to evaluate the indirect impact of COVID-19 and lockdown measures on sociodemographic inequalities in healthcare utilisation in seven Italian areas.
In this multicentre retrospective study, we evaluated whether COVID-19 modified the association between educational level or deprivation and indicators of hospital utilisation and quality of care. We also assessed variations in gradients by sex and age class. We estimated age-standardised rates and prevalence and their relative per cent changes comparing pandemic (2020) and pre-pandemic (2018-2019) periods, and the Relative Index of Inequalities (RIIs) fitting multivariable Poisson models with an interaction between socioeconomic position and period.
Compared with 2018-2019, hospital utilisation and, to a lesser extent, timeliness of procedures indicators fell during the first months of 2020. Larger declines were registered among women, the elderly and the low educated resulting in a shrinkage (or widening if RII <1) of the educational gradients for most of the indicators. Timeliness of procedures indicators did not show any educational gradient neither before nor during the pandemic. Inequalities by deprivation were nuanced and did not substantially change in 2020.
The socially patterned reduction of hospital utilisation may lead to a potential exacerbation of health inequalities among groups who were already vulnerable before the pandemic. The healthcare service can contribute to contrast health disparities worsened by COVID-19 through more efficient communication and locally appropriate interventions.
这场大流行可能会损害除新冠病毒疾病之外其他病症的医疗服务获取和利用的公平性。本研究的目的是评估新冠病毒疾病和封锁措施对意大利七个地区医疗保健利用方面社会人口不平等的间接影响。
在这项多中心回顾性研究中,我们评估了新冠病毒疾病是否改变了教育水平或贫困程度与医院利用指标及医疗质量之间的关联。我们还评估了按性别和年龄组划分的梯度变化。我们估计了年龄标准化率和患病率及其相对百分比变化,比较了大流行期间(2020年)和大流行前(2018 - 2019年),并通过拟合具有社会经济地位与时期交互作用的多变量泊松模型来计算不平等相对指数(RIIs)。
与2018 - 2019年相比,2020年头几个月医院利用率以及在较小程度上的手术及时性指标有所下降。女性、老年人和受教育程度低的人群下降幅度更大,导致大多数指标的教育梯度缩小(如果RII <1则扩大)。手术及时性指标在大流行之前和期间均未显示出任何教育梯度。贫困导致的不平等情况较为细微,2020年没有实质性变化。
医院利用率按社会模式下降可能会导致大流行之前就已处于弱势的群体之间健康不平等状况潜在加剧。医疗服务可通过更有效的沟通和因地制宜的干预措施来帮助应对因新冠病毒疾病而恶化的健康差距。