From the Department of Neurology (S.H., K.C.F., D.R.S.), Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore; Department of Biostatistics (M.A.G.-D.), Johns Hopkins University Bloomberg School of Public Health, Baltimore, MD; and of Internal Medicine (D.R.S.), University Teaching Hospital, Lusaka, Zambia.
Neurology. 2022 Oct 17;99(16):e1813-e1823. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000200962.
Multiple sclerosis (MS) prevalence varies widely by country and world region, variation that is often attributed to latitude and its association with vitamin D exposure. Given that increasing latitude is also associated with higher national wealth, this study investigated associations between MS prevalence and other factors driving regional differences, with a focus on sociodemographic, health systems, and lifestyle factors on a national and regional level.
Using data from multilateral organizations and scientific literature, an ecological study was conducted to evaluate associations between age- and sex-adjusted MS prevalence and prespecified sociodemographic (gross domestic product [GDP] per capita and gross national income [GNI] per capita), health systems (current health expenditure per capita and by percentage of GDP, universal health coverage [UHC] index, and medical doctors per capita), neurology-specific (MRI unit density and neurologists per capita), and lifestyle (obesity and tobacco use) factors. National, regional, and income-stratified data were aggregated and employed in relevant univariable and multivariable regression models. Stepwise variable selection techniques identified independent predictors of MS prevalence.
Univariable regression analyses showed significant associations at the national level for all investigated factors, except obesity prevalence and tobacco use. Latitude was significantly associated with MS prevalence in all world regions (β = 0.16-2.16), whereas the UHC index was significantly associated in 5 of 6 world regions (β = 0.18-3.17). MS prevalence was significantly associated with all factors except lifestyle factors and MRI unit density in high-income countries, but no associations were observed in low-income countries. Latitude was associated with MS prevalence for all income strata except low-income countries (β = 0.55-1.62). In multivariable analyses, current health expenditure per capita (β = 0.083, 95% CI 0.048-0.12, < 0.01) and latitude (β = 1.05, 95% CI 0.63-1.47, < 0.01) remained significantly associated with MS prevalence.
Health expenditure per capita is strongly associated with national MS prevalence, suggesting that theories that attribute variations in MS prevalence primarily to latitude effects on vitamin D are incomplete. Health care access significantly contributes to the global variations in MS prevalence, especially since national wealth rises with latitude and likely results in significant underestimation of MS prevalence in countries with lower health expenditure.
多发性硬化症(MS)的患病率在国家和世界区域之间存在很大差异,这种差异通常归因于纬度及其与维生素 D 暴露的关联。鉴于纬度的升高也与国家财富的增加有关,本研究调查了 MS 患病率与其他导致区域差异的因素之间的关联,重点关注国家和区域层面的社会人口统计学、卫生系统和生活方式因素。
使用多边组织和科学文献中的数据,进行了一项生态研究,以评估年龄和性别调整后的 MS 患病率与特定社会人口统计学(人均国内生产总值[GDP]和人均国民总收入[GNI])、卫生系统(人均当前卫生支出和占 GDP 的百分比、全民健康覆盖[UHC]指数和人均医生数量)、神经病学特定因素(MRI 单位密度和人均神经科医生数量)和生活方式因素(肥胖和吸烟)之间的关联。汇总了国家、区域和收入分层数据,并将其纳入相关的单变量和多变量回归模型中。逐步变量选择技术确定了 MS 患病率的独立预测因素。
单变量回归分析显示,除肥胖患病率和吸烟率外,所有调查因素在国家层面均具有显著相关性。纬度与所有世界区域的 MS 患病率均显著相关(β=0.16-2.16),而 UHC 指数在 6 个世界区域中的 5 个区域显著相关(β=0.18-3.17)。MS 患病率与除生活方式因素和 MRI 单位密度外的所有因素在高收入国家显著相关,但在低收入国家无相关性。纬度与除低收入国家外的所有收入阶层的 MS 患病率均相关(β=0.55-1.62)。在多变量分析中,人均当前卫生支出(β=0.083,95%CI 0.048-0.12,<0.01)和纬度(β=1.05,95%CI 0.63-1.47,<0.01)仍与 MS 患病率显著相关。
人均卫生支出与国家 MS 患病率密切相关,这表明将 MS 患病率的变化主要归因于纬度对维生素 D 影响的理论并不完整。卫生保健的获得对 MS 患病率的全球变化有重大贡献,特别是由于国家财富随着纬度的升高而增加,这可能导致卫生支出较低的国家对 MS 患病率的估计显著偏低。